Top executive commitment to the status quo: Some tests of its determinants

Donald C. Hambrick, Marta A. Geletkanycz, James W. Fredrickson

Strategic Management Journal · 1993 · 1.1K citations · 50 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Top executives vary in their commitment to the status quo, yet empirical studies often treat the psychological mechanisms behind this orientation as a black box. This study directly investigates the determinants of executives’ commitment to the status quo. The authors examine a set of previously suggested variables—such as industry tenure, organizational tenure, firm performance, and CEO succession expectations—that have not been directly tested for their influence on status‑quo commitment. Results show that industry tenure is a strong determinant of status‑quo commitment, outweighing organizational tenure, and that higher firm performance is positively linked to commitment, especially in high‑discretion industries, while incumbent CEOs tend to favor successors who resemble them.

Abstract

Abstract Some top executives are more committed to the status quo—particularly to their organization's current strategy and leadership profile—than are others. Most empirical research on upper echelons treats psychological phenomena as a ‘black box’—the unobserved intervening mechanisms—that causes associations between more observable executive characteristics and organizational outcomes. In contrast, this paper attempts to directly examine the determinants of an important element of an executive's psychological orientation—commitment to the status quo (CSQ). We focus on a select set of variables which have been posited in prior research as determinants of executive CSQ, but which have not been directly tested for such a relationship. Based on a large‐scale survey methodology, results suggest that an executive's tenure in an industry is a pronounced determinant of CSQ, and has significantly more impact than organizational tenure. As expected, the firm's current performance was found to be positively related to CSQ; this relationship was stronger in high‐discretion than in low‐discretion industries. Finally, the project reaffirms a well known human tendency: incumbent CEOs tend to believe that their eventual successors should be just like them.

References

50