Decision makers' hindsight bias after receiving favorable and unfavorable feedback.

Therese A. Louie

Journal of Applied Psychology · 1999 · 76 citations · 34 references

Concepts

Abstract

Two studies examined if decision makers show hindsight bias when feedback reflects upon their judgment. Study I investigated whether decision making heightens cognitive activity, and thereby reduces hindsight effects, or triggers self-serving mechanisms that prompt hindsight bias only when outcomes match favorably with decisions. Business students decided if they would purchase a company's stock, then received no feedback or feedback that the stock value increased or decreased. Consistent with a self-serving interpretation, relative to no-feedback participants, those whose outcomes matched favorably with their decisions showed hindsight bias and had a higher proportion of internal thoughts. In Study 2. favorable-feedback participants again showed hindsight bias, and had higher recall for decision-supportive items, but not when their tendency to take credit for success was suppressed. Discussion focuses on implications of decision makers' hindsight bias.

References

34