Which Comprehension? Artifacts in the Measurement of Reading Comprehension

Janet Ross Kendall, Jana M. Mason, William J. Hunter

The Journal of Educational Research · 1980 · 20 citations · 11 references

Concepts

Abstract

Differences in fifth graders’ reading comprehension scores were obtained using four different tasks typically employed to measure comprehension (multiple - choice, recall, cloze, and maze) and four different reading passages that were equated according to readability formulas. Data analyses revealed significant effects for passage, task, and an interaction between task and passage. It was concluded that the choice of a particular comprehension passage and testing procedure, whether in research or practice, does not allow generalization to other operational definitions of reading comprehension. These results suggest serious limitations of most contemporary reading comprehension research and testing.

References

11