Journal of Veterinary Medical Education · 2011 · 28 citations · 23 references
EducationMedical EducationVeterinary Internal MedicineFormative AssessmentPerformance AssessmentSmall Animal Internal MedicineClinical Performance AssessmentCompetency AssessmentSkills AssessmentStudent AssessmentStudent ReflectionStudent Self-assessmentFaculty MentoringMedical TrainingSelf-assessment AccuracySelf-assessment ComparisonSelf-assessment Of CompetenceSelf-assessment Of CompetenciesStudent Clinical CompetenceStudent Goal Setting
At the University of Minnesota, fourth-year veterinary students assessed their clinical competence after completion of a small-animal, internal-medicine clinical rotation using the same rotation assessment form used by supervising faculty. Grades were compared between the two groups. Students identified by faculty as low-performing were more likely to overestimate their competence in the areas of knowledge, clinical skill, and professionalism than were students identified by faculty as higher performing. This finding mirrors research results in human health professional training. Self-assessment should not be used as the primary or sole measure of clinical competence in veterinary medical training without the introduction of measures to ensure the accuracy of student self-assessment, measures that include active faculty mentoring of student self-assessment, student goal-setting and reflection, and availability of subsequent opportunities to practice additional self-assessment.
23
The assessment of clinical skills/competence/performance
George E. Miller · Academic Medicine · 1990 · 4.8K citations
Why People Fail to Recognize Their Own Incompetence
David Dunning, Kerri L. Johnson, Joyce Ehrlinger et al. · Current Directions in Psychological Science · 2003 · 1.2K citations
Medical studentsʼ clinical self-assessments
James O. Woolliscroft, Jocelyn D. Tenhaken, Julia M. Smith et al. · Academic Medicine · 1993 · 177 citations
Competency-Based Student Self-Assessment on a Surgery Rotation
D. Scott Lind, Stelios Rekkas, Vy T. Bui et al. · Journal of Surgical Research · 2002 · 138 citations