Modern Language Journal · 2015 · 368 citations · 56 references
Language StudiesLinguisticsSecond Language StudiesLanguage ProficiencySecond Language EducationSecond Language LearningCorrective FeedbackGrammarGrammar AcquisitionSecond Language AcquisitionWriting DevelopmentWriting ProficiencyAssessing L2 ProficiencyCorrective Feedback EffectivenessEnglish As A Second Language WritingL2 Written ProductionSecond Language TransferSecond Language Writing DevelopmentWritten Corrective Feedback
Written corrective feedback has attracted growing attention due to conceptual controversy and its widespread use. The study seeks to determine whether written corrective feedback improves second‑language grammatical accuracy and to identify factors that influence its effectiveness. A meta‑analysis of 21 primary studies was conducted to synthesize existing empirical evidence. The analysis found that written corrective feedback enhances grammatical accuracy, but its impact varies with learner proficiency, context, and task genre.
Written corrective feedback has been subject to increasing attention in recent years, in part because of the conceptual controversy surrounding it and in part because of its ubiquitous practice. This study takes a meta‐analytic approach to synthesizing extant empirical research, including 21 primary studies. Guiding the analysis are two questions: Does written corrective feedback help to improve the grammatical accuracy of second language writing? What factors might mitigate its efficacy? Results show that written corrective feedback can lead to greater grammatical accuracy in second language writing, yet its efficacy is mediated by a host of variables, including learners' proficiency, the setting, and the genre of the writing task.
56
Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences
Keith E. Muller, Jacob Cohen · Technometrics · 1989 · 83.9K citations
CORRECTIVE FEEDBACK AND LEARNER UPTAKE
Roy Lyster, Leila Ranta · Studies in Second Language Acquisition · 1997 · 2.2K citations
Education, Instruction, Teaching +16
The Case Against Grammar Correction in L2 Writing Classes
John Truscott · Language Learning · 1996 · 1.7K citations