Readability assessment of internet‐based patient education materials related to facial fractures

Saurin Sanghvi, Deepa V. Cherla, Pratik A. Shukla, Jean Anderson Eloy

The Laryngoscope · 2012 · 67 citations · 37 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Internet‑based patient education materials for facial fractures are widely available from professional societies, clinical practices, hospitals, and other sources, yet they often exceed the 6th‑grade reading level recommended by health authorities. This study evaluates the readability of facial‑fracture IPEMs and compares levels across four source types. The authors analyzed 41 facial‑fracture IPEMs retrieved from Google, applying Flesch‑Kincaid, Flesch Reading Ease, SMOG, and Gunning Fog indices, and compared mean scores across source categories with ANOVA and t‑tests. Only 4.9 % of the materials were at or below the 6th‑grade level, with mean scores indicating a difficult reading level (FKGL 9.89, SMOG 12.73, Gunning 12.98, FRES 54.10), meaning most facial‑fracture IPEMs exceed the recommended readability and would be hard for the average patient to understand.

Abstract

Abstract Objective/Hypothesis: Various professional societies, clinical practices, hospitals, and health care‐related Web sites provide Internet‐based patient education material (IPEMs) to the general public. However, this information may be written above the 6th‐grade reading level recommended by the US Department of Health and Human Services. The purpose of this study is to assess the readability of facial fracture (FF)‐related IPEMs and compare readability levels of IPEMs provided by four sources: professional societies, clinical practices, hospitals, and miscellaneous sources. Study Design: Analysis of IPEMs on FFs available on Google.com. Methods: The readability of 41 FF‐related IPEMs was assessed with four readability indices: Flesch‐Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL), Flesch Reading Ease Score (FRES), Simple Measure of Gobbledygook (SMOG), and Gunning Frequency of Gobbledygook (Gunning FOG). Averages were evaluated against national recommendations and between each source using analysis of variance and t tests. Results: Only 4.9% of IPEMs were written at or below the 6th‐grade reading level, based on FKGL. The mean readability scores were: FRES 54.10, FKGL 9.89, SMOG 12.73, and Gunning FOG 12.98, translating into FF‐related IPEMs being written at a “difficult” writing level, which is above the level of reading understanding of the average American adult. Conclusions: IPEMs related to FFs are written above the recommended 6th‐grade reading level. Consequently, this information would be difficult to understand by the average US patient.

References

37