Inclusion, School Restructuring, and the Remaking of American Society

Dorothy Kerzner Lipsky, Alan Gartner

Harvard Educational Review · 1996 · 268 citations · 22 references

TL;DR

The article reviews the implementation of PL 94‑142, noting that while it aimed to place students in the least restrictive environment, it actually facilitated the creation of separate educational systems for students with special needs. The authors aim to evaluate recent developments in special education against an inclusionary model, arguing that the special education system should not separate students with special needs. They analyze recent special education developments by comparing them to an inclusionary model. The authors conclude that inclusion delivers a quality, individualized, integrated education for all students, is supported by recent court rulings, and should be embraced as a social‑justice‑driven approach that reshapes school restructuring and American society.

Abstract

In this article, Dorothy Kerzner Lipsky and Alan Gartner discuss recent developments in special education and measure them against their inclusionary model. This article expands and updates their 1987 HER article, "Beyond Special Education: Toward a Quality System for All Students," a review of the implementation of PL 94-142, which, though the basis for placement in the least restrictive environment, in fact provided legal support for the development of separate educational systems for students with special needs. Here, Lipsky and Gartner continue their argument that the special education model must not separate those with special needs. They argue that inclusion provides all students with a quality education that is both individual and integrated, citing recent court cases that support their contention that all students can and should be educated in the same classroom. Lipsky and Gartner conclude by showing how their inclusionary model adds to the school restructuring debate, which until now has excluded any mention of students with disabilities. They believe that special education should be viewed as a matter of social justice and equity, and see inclusion as a way of both restructuring education and remaking American society.

References

22