Purchasing social responsibility and firm performance

Craig R. Carter

International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management · 2005 · 362 citations · 87 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Debate and mixed empirical evidence exist on whether socially responsible behavior improves or harms firm performance, and this study builds on literature from logistics, CSR, the resource‑based view, and organizational learning to frame the issue. The study investigates how purchasing social responsibility (PSR) affects firm costs and tests whether organizational learning and supplier performance mediate this relationship. Using a survey and structural equation modeling, the authors assess the link between PSR and supplier performance while examining the mediating role of organizational learning. Results show no direct PSR‑cost relationship, but PSR leads to organizational learning and better supplier performance, which together reduce costs, thereby explaining prior conflicting findings and demonstrating PSR’s tangible benefits.

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to examine how socially responsible supply management activities, a term labeled purchasing social responsibility (PSR) in the extant literature, affect a firm's costs. There has been much debate, and mixed empirical findings, regarding whether socially responsible behavior on the part of companies improves or reduces firm performance. Design/methodology/approach A survey methodology and structural equation modeling are used to assess the relationship between PSR and supplier performance, including the mediating role of organizational learning. The theoretical scope is developed through an integration of literature from logistics, corporate social responsibility, the resource‐based view of the firm, and organizational learning. Findings No direct relationship is found between PSR and costs; however, organizational learning and supplier performance act as key, mediating variables between PSR and costs, with PSR leading to organizational learning, improved supplier performance, and ultimately reduced costs. Research limitations/implications The significant mediating roles of organizational learning and supplier performance provide one possible explanation for the past, conflicting findings of studies that have investigated the direct relationship between corporate social responsibility and firm performance. Practical implications The findings suggest that PSR not only is the “right thing to do”, but also can lead to significant improvements in supplier performance and costs. Originality/value This is the first study to suggest and test the possibility of mediation between social responsibility and firm performance. The research also extends the integration of organizational learning and supply chain management.

References

87