The Turnover Dilemma: A Disease with Solutions

Karen Barrett, T. F. Riggar, Carl R. Flowers, William Crimando, Tammy Lynn Bailey

Journal of rehabilitation · 1997 · 12 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

An insidious persistent problem has plagued rehabilitation for several decades. This dilemma is both an enigma and a well known documented phenomenon. One aspect directly affects professional psychological well-being and occupational health, and yet another component threatens to undermine programs by severely degrading organizational effectiveness. This dilemma which continues unabated, and appears to be increasing, strikes at rehabilitation personnel turnover. This disease, as with all true epidemics, transcends artificial boundaries as research from New Zealand (Flett, Biggs, & Alpass, 1995b), Australia (Chinnery et al., 1995), and Israel (Rimmerman, 1989) has indicated. Overwork, downsizing, cost containment, little reward or recognition, and a long list of other factors have been shown to lead to stress and burnout, and subsequently to people leaving jobs which cause them harm (Riggar, 1985). So pervasive are some of these variables in modern life that Hall and Ward (1996) reported that four of five internists/family practitioners indicate that for people as young as 35 years of age that work and personal stress contributed significantly (86%) to diminished memory and lack of concentration. However, factors such as job dissatisfaction, excessive paperwork, unfeeling bureaucracies, and other known particulars do not in and of themselves, with certainty, result in personnel turnover. Although the number of articles concerning stress, burnout, job satisfaction, mental health, and working life/values in rehabilitation exceeds 126 in number (Riggar, Barrett, & Crimando, 1996) most of the studies address personal or personnel concerns primarily as individual phenomena related to work. While few studies have addressed fiscal cost, but rather psychological cost, even less are actual examinations of organizational bottom-line costs, namely, personnel turnover. Adams, Barrett, and Flowers (1995) directed a recent needs assessment of community rehabilitation programs in RSA (Rehabilitation Services Administration) Region V (Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Minnesota), which included questions on staff turnover rates. Rates (see Table 1) averaged 18.3% for supervisory/management staff and 28.6% for direct service; they ranged from a low of 9% for supervisory/management staff in Ohio, to 57% among Illinois direct services staff. These data were the catalyst for this article. The purpose of this study was to examine the status of personnel turnover in rehabilitation agencies, facilities, and organizations, comparing the findings in past analyses to illustrate potential trends. In addition to negative personal aspects and decreased organizational capabilities, consequences of the dilemma -- often resulting in staff neglect -- are revealed through an examination of turnover costs. Table 1 Average Annual Staff Turnover within Community Rehabilitation Programs in Region V Average Annual Turnover: Average Annual Turnover: Supervisory/Management Staff Direct Service Staff REGION V 18.3% 28.6% (N=295) ILLINOIS (N=79) 14% 57% INDIANA (N=32) 22% 22% MICHIGAN (N=67) 18% 20% MINNESOTA (N=25) 32% 40% OHIO (N=65) 9% 15% WISCONSIN (N=27) 15% 18% Method Sample Comprehensive needs assessment questionnaires were mailed to 1713 facilities, agencies, and organizations within RSA Region V (Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio, and Wisconsin). The organizations receiving these surveys constituted all facilities accredited in the region by CARF - The Rehabilitation Accreditation Commission (CARF), in the areas of Employment and Community Support at the time of the mailing. …