Active Versus Passive Learning in Large-Group Sessions in Medical School: A Randomized Cross-Over Trial Investigating Effects on Learning and the Feeling of Learning

Peter Boedeker, Tobias R. Schlingmann, Joshua A. Kailin, Ajith Nair, Cara Foldes, David R. Rowley, Katherine B. Salciccioli, Ronald Maag, Nancy Moreno, Nadia Ismail

Medical Science Educator · 2024 · 25 citations · 13 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Purpose: The evidence base for active learning in medical education is based largely on trials with suspect internal validity. We empirically compared the learning and feeling of learning of participants when in large-group interactive sessions and passive lectures using a rigorous trial capable of providing an unambiguous assessment of effect. Further, we evaluated if there was a differential effect based on prior achievement. Materials and Method: We conducted a two-day randomized cross-over trial with 146 s-year medical students. Passive learning involved lecture-based case presentation with minimal interaction; in the large-group interactive session, students worked in teams on the same cases. Participants completed a test of learning and a feeling of learning survey. Effects were estimated using linear mixed-effects models. Results: < 0.001). Conclusions: Transformation of passive lectures to interactive learning sessions is feasible, has the potential to close achievement gaps by benefiting the lowest achieving learners the most, and provides students a greater sense of learning than passive lectures. Supplementary Information: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s40670-024-02219-1.

References

13