Slicing the cake without baking it: Opportunistic platform entry strategies in digital markets

Kimmo Karhu, Paavo Ritala

Long Range Planning · 2020 · 72 citations · 61 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Digital platforms grow through the generative nature of digital resources and openness, which create strong network effects and winner‑take‑all dynamics that protect incumbents yet also expose them to entrant strategies that capture value without upfront investment. The study identifies three opportunistic entry strategies—platform exploitation, injection, and pacing—that allow entrants to leverage incumbent ecosystems. These strategies enable entrants to capture value by copying parts of incumbent resources, following the development cycle of key boundary resources, or embedding themselves within the platform. The analysis shows that such unconventional strategies extend beyond traditional competitive dimensions like quality, variety, and network size.

Abstract

The growth of digital platforms relies on the generative nature of digital resources and platforms' openness to complementary innovation. These features often generate strong network effects and winner-take-all dynamics that protect incumbents from competition. However, under certain conditions, these same features render incumbent platforms vulnerable to competitive strategic moves via entrant platforms wherein the entrants can capture value and simultaneously avoid upfront investments in value creation. In this study, we identify three such strategies: platform exploitation, platform injection, and platform pacing. These strategies allow the entrant platform to capture value using the incumbent ecosystem's resources by copying parts of the resources (exploitation), by following the development cycle of key boundary resources (pacing), or by placing itself inside the platform (injection). In this study, we employ an interpretative cross-case synthesis to both theorize these strategies as a new category of opportunistic platform competition and to reveal their distinctive characteristics. Overall, the study demonstrates the potential for unconventional and opportunistic platform competition strategies that extend beyond more traditional ones, such as quality, variety, and network size.

References

61