Plurilingualism amid the panoply of lingualisms: addressing critiques and misconceptions in education

Steve Marshall, Danièle Moore

International Journal of Multilingualism · 2016 · 156 citations · 23 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Scholars today confront a spectrum of lingualisms, and plurilingualism is defined as the study of individuals’ dynamic language repertoires and agency across contexts, with languages and cultures interrelating over time. The authors examine how plurilingualism relates to other lingualisms and illustrate its pedagogical application at a Vancouver university. They compare plurilingualism to other lingualisms and present a case study of university pedagogy. The study refutes three critiques: that plurilingualism relies on a static social–individual binary, that it is overly agentive, and that it may reinforce social inequities.

Abstract

Today, scholars and students face an array of lingualisms: bilingualism, multilingualism, polylingualism, metrolingualism plurilingualism, codeswitching, codemeshing, and translanguaging, among others. Plurilingualism can be understood as the study of individuals' repertoires and agency in several languages, in different contexts, in which the individual is the locus and actor of contact; accordingly, a person's languages and cultures interrelate and change over time, depending on individual biographies, social trajectories, and life paths. The term 'plurilingual competence' adds emphasis on learners' agency, and constraints and opportunities in educational contexts. We discuss where and how plurilingualism fits among the other lingualisms, its similarities and differences, with an example of plurilingual pedagogy and practice from a university in Vancouver, Canada. In doing so, we challenge three common critiques of/misconceptions about plurilingualism: (i) that it is based on an invalid static binary between the social and the individual, (ii) that it is over-agentive, and (iii) that it can serve to reinforce social inequities within a neoliberal world order.

References

23