Quality in MOOCs: Surveying the Terrain

Nina Hood, Allison Littlejohn

ResearchSpace (University of Auckland) · 2016 · 25 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

MOOCs are re-operationalising traditional concepts in education. While they draw on elements of existing educational and learning models, they represent a new approach to instruction and learning. The challenges MOOCs present to traditional education models have important implications for approaching and assessing quality. The purpose of this review is to identify quality measures and to highlight some of the tensions surrounding notions of quality, as well as the need for new ways of thinking about and approaching quality in MOOCs. It draws on the literature on both MOOCs and quality in education more generally in order to provide a framework for thinking about quality and the different variables and questions that must be considered when conceptualising quality in MOOCs. The review adopts a relativist approach, positioning quality as a measure for a specific purpose. The meaning and purpose ascribed to education shifts depending on the context and the actor, with governments, institutions, instructors and learners approaching education from different viewpoints and consequently viewing quality through different lenses. The review draws upon Biggs’s (1993) 3P model to explore notions and dimensions of quality in relation to MOOCs. Biggs conceptualised education as a complex set of interacting ecosystems, with each ecosystem divided into three types of variables — presage, process and product variables — which correspond to an input–environment–output model. The review identifies and examines a wide range of presage, process and product variables applicable to MOOCs, as well as exploring the relationships that have been found to exist between them. It brings together literature examining how quality should be interpreted and assessed in MOOCs at a more general and theoretical level, as well as empirical research studies that explore how these ideas about quality can be operationalised, including the measures and instruments that can be employed. What emerges from the literature are the complexities involved in interpreting and measuring quality in MOOCs and the importance of both context and perspective to discussions of quality.