A Comparison of Instructional Methods for Improving the Spatial-Visualization Ability of Freshman Technology Seminar Students

Chip Ferguson

2008 · 29 citations · 15 references

Concepts

Abstract

The purpose of the current pilot study was to investigate teaching methods for improving spatial visualization (SV) ability. Specifically, this pilot study sought to determine the effects of mechanical dissection manipulatives on improving the SV ability of freshmen enrolled in a Technology Systems course at Western Carolina University (WCU). For industry to remain competitive in the global marketplace, students graduating from engineering and technology programs must have strong SV abilities in order to communicate effectively and grow professionally in an engineering career. Researchers have previously investigated instructional methods for improving SV ability, however, only a small number of studies have been conducted, with no clear consensus showing the superiority of a certain approach. Two, five-week (15 hours total) instructional methods developed to influence the SV ability of the 31 students were randomly assigned to the two course sections of Technology Systems. Treatment E group received lectures and exercises on engineering drawing principles and practices while Treatment EM group received hand-held mechanical dissection manipulatives for use in lectures and exercises on engineering drawing principles and practices. The researcher administered a demographic and experience survey at the beginning of the study. The Purdue Spatial Visualization Test: Rotations was used as the pre-post measure of SV ability. The pilot study yielded several major findings. There was a statistically significant difference in the pre-post scores for Group EM, but no significant difference for Group E. There was no significant difference in the effectiveness of the two group treatments E and EM. Within Group E, STEM majors had greater PSVT:ROT gains than non-STEM majors. Conversely, within groups EM, non-STEM majors had greater gains than STEM majors. Group E High Previous Experience participants had greater PSVT:ROT gains than Low Previous Experience Participants and Group EM Low Previous Experience participants had greater PSVT:ROT gains as compared to High Previous Experience participants.

References

15