Protein Science · 2016 · 232 citations · 54 references
Life SciencesBiologyEvolutionary BiologyEnzymologyMolecular EvolutionProtein EngineeringEnzyme DesignEnzyme EvolutionEpistasisEvolutionary Trajectory AnalysisProtein Engineering Of EnzymesProtein EvolutionAdaptive EvolutionAdaptive Protein EvolutionEnzymesEpistasis AnalysisEpistasis In Protein EvolutionEvolutionary TrajectoriesMutational EffectsProtein Engineering Trajectories
Mutational epistasis, where a mutation’s effect depends on genetic background, introduces non‑additive unpredictability that hampers protein design, yet a consensus view on its extent remains lacking. This study systematically analyzes epistasis across nine adaptive trajectories toward novel enzymatic functions. Epistasis was quantified by comparing mutation effects between the wild‑type starting enzyme and intermediate variants along each trajectory. The analysis revealed pervasive positive epistasis, with nearly half of functional mutations neutral or deleterious on the wild type but beneficial later, often driven by long‑range indirect interactions, underscoring the need to incorporate epistasis into protein engineering.
There has been much debate about the extent to which mutational epistasis, that is, the dependence of the outcome of a mutation on the genetic background, constrains evolutionary trajectories. The degree of unpredictability introduced by epistasis, due to the non-additivity of functional effects, strongly hinders the strategies developed in protein design and engineering. While many studies have addressed this issue through systematic characterization of evolutionary trajectories within individual enzymes, the field lacks a consensus view on this matter. In this work, we performed a comprehensive analysis of epistasis by analyzing the mutational effects from nine adaptive trajectories toward new enzymatic functions. We quantified epistasis by comparing the effect of mutations occurring between two genetic backgrounds: the starting enzyme (for example, wild type) and the intermediate variant on which the mutation occurred during the trajectory. We found that most trajectories exhibit positive epistasis, in which the mutational effect is more beneficial when it occurs later in the evolutionary trajectory. Approximately half (49%) of functional mutations were neutral or negative on the wild-type background, but became beneficial at a later stage in the trajectory, indicating that these functional mutations were not predictable from the initial starting point. While some cases of strong epistasis were associated with direct interaction between residues, many others were caused by long-range indirect interactions between mutations. Our work highlights the prevalence of epistasis in enzyme adaptive evolution, in particular positive epistasis, and suggests the necessity of incorporating mutational epistasis in protein engineering and design to create highly efficient catalysts.
54
Darwinian Evolution Can Follow Only Very Few Mutational Paths to Fitter Proteins
Daniel Weinreich, Nigel F. Delaney, Mark A. DePristo et al. · Science · 2006 · 1.5K citations
Deep mutational scanning: a new style of protein science
Douglas M. Fowler, Stanley Fields · Nature Methods · 2014 · 1.5K citations · Full text
Protein Sectors: Evolutionary Units of Three-Dimensional Structure
Najeeb Halabi, Olivier Rivoire, Stanislas Leibler et al. · Cell · 2009 · 750 citations · Full text
Life Sciences, Biochemistry, Biology +15
Repeatability and Contingency in the Evolution of a Key Innovation in Phage Lambda
Justin R. Meyer, Devin T. Dobias, Joshua S. Weitz et al. · Science · 2012 · 540 citations · Full text