MIS Quarterly · 1992 · 364 citations · 50 references
Public HealthInformation SystemsManagement Information SystemsImplementation ScienceInformation Systems DevelopmentInformation Systems ManagementDeterminants Of ImplementationImplementation AnalysisImplementation EvaluationImplementation OutcomesImplementation StrategiesSystem ImplementationConstruct ValidityImplementation Outcomes MeasurementMeta-analytic ComparisonMeta-analytic CovariatesMeta-analytic StratificationQuantitative EvidenceResearch Priority SettingSituational Variables
Information systems are increasingly critical to firms, and growing investment in their design and development has made implementation a high‑priority research area, yet the extent of cumulative progress in the literature remains unclear. The study aims to conduct a rigorous, quantitative review of empirical DSS implementation literature to provide guidelines for implementation management and future research. Meta‑analysis of 144 findings from 33 studies shows that user‑situational variables such as involvement, training, and experience are more critical than psychological factors for DSS implementation success, can boost success by up to 30 %, and highlights methodological insights and specific research domains for future work.
Information systems are becoming increasingly critical to the daily operations and success of many firms. This, combined with the rising investments in design and development of these systems, make implementation a high priority research topic. Although information systems implementation has been a topic of interest to researchers over the past two decades, the extent to which the existing body of research reflects substantial and cumulative development is not entirely clear.The objective of this study is to conduct a rigorous and quantitative review of the empirical DSS implementation literature as a basis for providing guidelines for implementation management and conduct of future research. Meta-analysis of 144 findings from3 3 studies indicates that user-situational variables (involvement, training and experience) are more important than psychological factors to DSS implementation success and that user-situational variables can improve the implementation success by as much as 30 percent. Furthermore, the meta-analytic findings regarding the methodological characteristics of studies provide useful insights for the design of future research studies of implementation. The findings also allow us to put into perspective the incremental contribution of additional substantive and empirical studies in this area. Additionally, several specific domains (e.g., construct validation research on user involvement and causal modeling) might profit most form future research efforts.
50
The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results.
Robert Rosenthal · Psychological Bulletin · 1979 · 8.6K citations
The nature and causes of job satisfaction
Edwin A. Locke · Medical Entomology and Zoology · 1976 · 6.1K citations
Meta-Analysis: Cumulating Research Findings across Studies
Jack M. Feldman, John E. Hunter, Frank L. Schmidt et al. · Academy of Management Review · 1984 · 1.2K citations