Adult Education Quarterly · 2010 · 229 citations · 10 references
EducationAdult EducationEducational PsychologyEpistemologyPedagogyPhilosophy Of MindConsciousnessEmbodied LearningEmbodied PracticeExperiential LearningReflectionReflective PracticeLearner ReflectionReflective Practice Models
Reflection is a widely used concept in learning theories, often defined as a rational analytical process that extracts knowledge from experience. The article critiques the cognitive bias in defining reflection and argues for an embodied experiential perspective that integrates body and mind in learning. The author uses Gendlin’s Focusing as an example and proposes elements of experiential learning to form an integrative framework for reflection.
The concept of reflection is common to a range of learning theories and therefore carries various meanings and differing significance. Within theories of adult education, reflection is predominantly conceptualized as the rational analytical process through which human beings extract knowledge from their experience. This article critiques this cognitive bias. However, the author argues that a perspective of embodied experiential learning should not give preference to the body over the mind as a source of knowledge. Nor should researchers reject reflection as an exclusively cognitive process. Reflective practices can facilitate a learning dialogue between our implicit embodied experience and conceptual aspects of our consciousness. The author illustrates this with the example of the theory and practice of Gendlin’s Focusing. In conclusion, the author proposes a set of elements, characteristic of individual and collective human experiential learning, that can provide a framework for a more expansive and integrative conceptualization of reflection.
10
Ella Flagg Young · Journal of Education · 1916 · 291 citations
Experiential Learning: A Theoretical Critique from Five Perspectives
Tara Fenwick · 2001 · 241 citations
Education, Instruction, Teaching +13
There's No Such Thing As Reflection
Graham Ixer · The British Journal of Social Work · 1999 · 197 citations