BMC Medical Research Methodology · 2015 · 71 citations · 16 references
Public HealthPopulation Health SciencesEpidemiologic MethodsEpidemiologyWomen's HealthAnthropometric VariationBody CompositionCohort StudiesMeasures Of AssociationAnthropometric ComparisonAnthropometryHuman Body MeasurementsLongitudinal Cohort StudiesProspective Cohort DataRegression Dilution BiasWaist Circumference MeasurementWaist-to-hip Ratio
BACKGROUND: In prospective epidemiological studies, anthropometry is often self-reported and may be subject to reporting errors. Self-reported anthropometric data are reasonably accurate when compared with measurements made at the same time, but reporting errors and changes over time in anthropometric characteristics could potentially generate time-dependent biases in disease-exposure associations. METHODS: In a sample of about 4000 middle-aged UK women from a large prospective cohort study, we compared repeated self-reports of weight, height, derived body mass index, and waist and hip circumferences, obtained between 1999 and 2008, with clinical measurements taken in 2008. For self-reported and measured values of each variable, mean differences, correlation coefficients, and regression dilution ratios (which measure relative bias in estimates of linear association) were compared over time. RESULTS: For most variables, the differences between self-reported and measured values were small. On average, reported values tended to be lower than measured values (i.e. under-reported) for all variables except height; under-reporting was greatest for waist circumference. As expected, the greater the elapsed time between self-report and measurement, the larger the mean differences between them (each P < 0.001 for trend), and the weaker their correlations (each P < 0.004 for trend). Regression dilution ratios were in general close to 1.0 and did not vary greatly over time. CONCLUSION: Reporting errors in anthropometric variables may result in small biases to estimates of associations with disease outcomes. Weaker correlations between self-reported and measured values would result in some loss of study power over time. Overall, however, our results provide new evidence that self-reported anthropometric variables remain suitable for use in analyses of associations with disease outcomes in cohort studies over at least a decade of follow-up.
16
Breast cancer and hormone-replacement therapy in the Million Women Study
Valerie Beral · The Lancet · 2003 · 3K citations
Medicine, Endocrinology, Oncology +13
Validity of self-reported height and weight in 4808 EPIC–Oxford participants
Elizabeth Spencer, Paul N. Appleby, Gwyneth K. Davey et al. · Public Health Nutrition · 2002 · 1.1K citations · Full text
Self-reported weight and height
ML Rowland · American Journal of Clinical Nutrition · 1990 · 1K citations