Journal of Medical Ethics · 2008 · 274 citations · 13 references
HumanitiesMedical EducationTeachingBioethicsEthicsMedical EthicsApplied EthicsHealthcare EthicsMoral PhilosophyProfessional EthicsContextual EpistemologyDeliberationHealthcare InstitutionsMoral DeliberationProfessional Medical Ethics
Traditional medical ethics teaching focuses on imparting theoretical knowledge, reflecting an epistemological view that moral expertise resides in theory rather than in healthcare professionals' moral experience. The paper introduces moral case deliberation, an alternative contextual teaching approach grounded in pragmatic‑hermeneutical and dialogical ethics, and illustrates it with a Dutch psychiatric hospital project. Moral case deliberation involves healthcare professionals presenting real moral questions in structured dialogues, guided by an ethicist who employs conversational methods to uncover answers and build moral competencies, and is embedded as a routine part of workplace training; the Dutch hospital project was evaluated with responsive evaluation. Responsive evaluation yielded rich insights into the implementation process and its effects, and the research itself reinforced the implementation.
A traditional approach to teaching medical ethics aims to provide knowledge about ethics. This is in line with an epistemological view on ethics in which moral expertise is assumed to be located in theoretical knowledge and not in the moral experience of healthcare professionals. The aim of this paper is to present an alternative, contextual approach to teaching ethics, which is grounded in a pragmatic-hermeneutical and dialogical ethics. This approach is called moral case deliberation. Within moral case deliberation, healthcare professionals bring in their actual moral questions during a structured dialogue. The ethicist facilitates the learning process by using various conversation methods in order to find answers to the case and to develop moral competencies. The case deliberations are not unique events, but are a structural part of the professional training on the work floor within healthcare institutions. This article presents the underlying theory on (teaching) ethics and illustrates this approach with an example of a moral case deliberation project in a Dutch psychiatric hospital. The project was evaluated using the method of responsive evaluation. This method provided us with rich information about the implementation process and effects the research process itself also lent support to the process of implementation.
13
Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation.
Maurice Bloch, Jean Lave, Étienne Wenger · Man · 1994 · 39.8K citations