The Learning Organization, Power, Politics and Ideology Introduction

John Coopey

Management Learning · 1995 · 240 citations · 22 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The paper develops three main criticisms of the learning organization concept. The authors find that the concept is flawed because it ignores political dynamics, offers only modest employee empowerment while strengthening managerial power, and serves as a vehicle for managerial ideology that limits employee agency.

Abstract

Three main criticisms of the 'learning organization' are developed in this paper. First, it is argued that the concept is badly flawed because of its proponents' apolitical assumptions. This leads them to neglect the political activity likely to be encountered in a learning organization, activity which will tend to frustrate the learning aims. Second, while their model allows for greater employee empowerment the amount will probably be relatively modest in real terms. On the other hand, the power of managers, especially those at the apex of the organization, is likely to be enhanced by their privileged access to any extra informational and symbolic resources that are created by individual and collective learning processes. The third, and potentially the most damning, criticism is that the concept of the 'learning organization' is expressed in ways that provide raw material for managerial ideology, potentially constraining the meanings and actions of other employees so that they support the interests of the dominant coalition.

References

22