Corporate Social Responsibility: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

Subhabrata Bobby Banerjee

Critical Sociology · 2008 · 1.5K citations · 49 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The article critically analyzes contemporary discourses of corporate social responsibility, sustainability, and corporate citizenship, offering an alternative view that they are ideological tools legitimizing corporate power and questioning the concept of organizational stakeholders. The author contends that these discourses, though framed as emancipatory, are driven by narrow business interests that curtail external stakeholders, that stakeholder theory functions as a colonial mechanism regulating stakeholder behavior, and concludes with implications for critical management studies.

Abstract

In this article I critically analyze contemporary discourses of corporate social responsibility and related discourses of sustainability and corporate citizenship. I argue that despite their emancipatory rhetoric, discourses of corporate citizenship, social responsibility and sustainability are defined by narrow business interests and serve to curtail interests of external stakeholders. I provide an alternate perspective, one that views discourses of corporate citizenship, corporate social responsibility, and sustainability as ideological movements that are intended to legitimize and consolidate the power of large corporations. I also problematize the popular notion of organizational `stakeholders'. I argue that stakeholder theory of the firm represents a form of stakeholder colonialism that serves to regulate the behavior of stakeholders. I conclude by discussing implications for critical management studies.

References

49