Cross‐cultural model testing: toward a solution of the etic‐emic dilemma

Andrew R. Davidson, James Jaccard, Harry C. Triandis, Maria Luisa Morales, Rogelio Díaz‐Guerrero

International Journal of Psychology · 1976 · 251 citations · 13 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The model’s elements are etic, yet the variables were operationalized emically. Triandis’s behavior‑prediction model was tested on U.S. and Mexican women for fertility‑related behaviors.

Abstract

A model for the prediction of behavior from attitudinal components, developed by Triandis, was tested with samples of U.S. and Mexican women, and with fertility relevant behaviors. The elements of the model are etic, but the operationalizations of the various variables were done emically. Results support the model in both cultures. While the predictive utility of the model is equivalent in two cultures, there are social class differences on which component of the model is most emphasized. The U.S. upper‐middle‐class sample and the Mexican upper‐middle‐class sample emphasized the person's attitude toward the act, while the Mexican lower SES (socio‐economic status) sample emphasized the person's normative beliefs (moral obligations).

References

13