Testing for adventitious presence of transgenic material in conventional seed or grain lots using quantitative laboratory methods: statistical procedures and their implementation

Abstract

When the laboratory methods employed are qualitative, the statistical methodologies used in testing for the adventitious presence (AP) of transgenic material in conventional seed and grain lots are well defined. However, when the response from the method used by the laboratory is quantitative (e.g. percent transgenic DNA), the statistical methodologies developed for qualitative laboratory methods are not fully appropriate. In this paper, we present the details of procedures specific to quantitative laboratory methods. In particular we consider: (1) the assessment of quantitative laboratory method errors using linear modelling; and (2) the process of deciding whether or not a lot meets pre-specified purity standards, including the development of probability calculations needed to develop operating characteristic curves and estimate consumer and producer risks for a given lower quality limit (LQL), acceptable quality limit (AQL) and testing plan. We also describe implementation of this approach in a useful spreadsheet application.