Review of Educational Research · 2014 · 215 citations · 108 references
EducationInstructionScience EducationArgumentation In Science EducationPedagogyScience InstructionArgument ConstructionArgumentationClassroom DiscussionScience PedagogyScientific InquiryScientific ReasoningArgumentation In Science LearningEpistemic ArgumentationScience Classroom DiscourseScientific Argumentation InstructionSociocultural LearningStudent Argument ConstructionStudent Argumentation
Science educators increasingly seek to support students’ participation in scientific practices, particularly epistemic practices, that is, those that ground authority for knowing in the discipline. Argumentation is one practice that has received significant attention in the research literature. However, scholars who take a sociocultural stance increasingly suggest that current conceptualizations are not sufficient for characterizing and supporting important aspects of scientific practice. In this article, I explore how students’ argumentation can be brought into closer alignment with that of scientists. I identify consequential differences in the contexts in which scientists and students typically enact argumentation and discuss how these differences have been addressed in the literature. Finally, I propose several directions for further research: embedding argumentation in uncertain scientific activity, supporting students to contest both what they know and their means of knowing, building more carefully from students’ resources, and attending to the development of epistemic cultures in classrooms.
108
Situated Cognition and the Culture of Learning
John Seely Brown, Allan Collins, Paul Duguid · Educational Researcher · 1989 · 13K citations · Full text
Identity and agency in cultural worlds
Choice Reviews Online · 1999 · 4.1K citations
Talking science: language, learning, and values
Jay L. Lemke · Choice Reviews Online · 1991 · 4K citations · Full text
Epistemic cultures: how the sciences make knowledge
Choice Reviews Online · 1999 · 3.4K citations