Affirmative Action and Labor Markets

James P. Smith, Finis Welch

Journal of Labor Economics · 1984 · 138 citations · 2 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Affirmative action remains controversial, extending from antidiscrimination legislation to debates over its labor‑market effects. This paper provides a progress report on our recent efforts at detecting the effects of affirmative action on minority wages and employment. The study finds that wage gains for black workers occurred mainly before 1974, before robust affirmative‑action monitoring, and that when EEOC/OFCC powers were strongest, wage effects for young blacks were counter‑intuitive, with employment shifting toward firms most exposed to monitoring—raising concerns about the timing and reliability of EEO‑1 data.

Abstract

Affirmative action remains controversial. The controversy extends from the original antidiscrimination legislation and its interpretation to estimates of affirmative action's effect on the labor market. This paper provides a progress report on our recent efforts at detecting the effects of affirmative action on minority wages and employment. Although we find a substantial increase in wages for black men and black women over our sample period, the timing of these wage changes is surprising. Most of the wage gains came prior to 1974, before the establishment of an effective monitoring structure for affirmative action. Indeed, when the powers of the EEOC and OFCC are greatest, the wage effects for young blacks are somewhat perverse. Using EEO-1 reports we find a major shift in black employment toward firms most vulnerable to the monitoring and potential sanctions of the affirmative action programs. As with wages, the shift in minority employment came prior to the expansion of the powers and budgets of the EEOC and OFCC. We are surprised by the timing of these changes and are concerned about the quality of the EEO-1 reports.

References

2