DNA-binding Specificity Is a Major Determinant of the Activity and Toxicity of Zinc-finger Nucleases

Abstract

The engineering of proteins to manipulate cellular genomes has developed into a promising technology for biomedical research, including gene therapy. In particular, zinc-finger nucleases (ZFNs), which consist of a nonspecific endonuclease domain tethered to a tailored zinc-finger (ZF) DNA-binding domain, have proven invaluable for stimulating homology-directed gene repair in a variety of cell types. However, previous studies demonstrated that ZFNs could be associated with significant cytotoxicity due to cleavage at off-target sites. Here, we compared the in vitro affinities and specificities of nine ZF DNA-binding domains with their performance as ZFNs in human cells. The results of our cell-based assays reveal that the DNA-binding specificity—in addition to the affinity—is a major determinant of ZFN activity and is inversely correlated with ZFN-associated toxicity. In addition, our data provide the first evidence that engineering strategies, which account for context-dependent DNA-binding effects, yield ZFs that function as highly efficient ZFNs in human cells. The engineering of proteins to manipulate cellular genomes has developed into a promising technology for biomedical research, including gene therapy. In particular, zinc-finger nucleases (ZFNs), which consist of a nonspecific endonuclease domain tethered to a tailored zinc-finger (ZF) DNA-binding domain, have proven invaluable for stimulating homology-directed gene repair in a variety of cell types. However, previous studies demonstrated that ZFNs could be associated with significant cytotoxicity due to cleavage at off-target sites. Here, we compared the in vitro affinities and specificities of nine ZF DNA-binding domains with their performance as ZFNs in human cells. The results of our cell-based assays reveal that the DNA-binding specificity—in addition to the affinity—is a major determinant of ZFN activity and is inversely correlated with ZFN-associated toxicity. In addition, our data provide the first evidence that engineering strategies, which account for context-dependent DNA-binding effects, yield ZFs that function as highly efficient ZFNs in human cells.