Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning Memory and Cognition · 2005 · 346 citations · 50 references
Social SciencesBehavioral SciencesPsychologyCognitive PsychologyExperimental DesignExperimental PsychologyCognitive Task AnalysisProblem SolvingVerbal BehaviorDesign-based Problem SolvingFixation EffectsPictorial Instructions
The study examined whether pictorial examples could cause negative transfer in nonexpert design problem solvers. Experiment 1 employed 89 think‑aloud participants in three conditions (control, fixation, defixation) and assessed negative transfer through verbal protocols, while Experiment 2 tested fixation effects with 60 non‑verbalizing participants. Participants tended to follow problematic examples, but defixating instructions reduced fixation effects.
Two experiments examined possible negative transfer in nonexperts from the use of pictorial examples in a laboratory design problem-solving situation. In Experiment 1, 89 participants were instructed to "think aloud" and were assigned to 1 of 3 conditions: (a) control (standard instructions), (b) fixation (inclusion of a problematic example, describing its problematic elements), or (c) defixation (inclusion of a problematic example, with instructions to avoid using problematic elements). Negative transfer due to examples was measured both quantitatively and qualitatively through verbal protocols. Verbal protocols (N = 176) were analyzed for participants' reasons for reference to the examples. In Experiment 2, fixation to examples was evaluated in nonverbalizing participants (N = 60). Results of both experiments suggest that (a) although participants consulted the problem instructions, they tended to follow the examples even when they included inappropriate elements and (b) the fixation effects can be diminished with the use of defixating instructions.
50
Structure‐Mapping: A Theoretical Framework for Analogy*
Dedre Gentner · Cognitive Science · 1983 · 5.1K citations
Protocol Analysis: Verbal Reports as Data
M. Venkatesan, K. Anders Ericsson, Herbert A. Simon · Journal of Marketing Research · 1986 · 4.4K citations
Schema induction and analogical transfer
Mary L. Gick, Keith J. Holyoak · Cognitive Psychology · 1983 · 2.9K citations · Full text