Assessment: The engine of systemic curricular reform?

Mary Barnes, David Clarke, Max Stephens

Journal of Curriculum Studies · 2000 · 85 citations · 6 references

Concepts

Abstract

We sought to examine empirically the prevailing assumption that changing assess-ment can leverage curricular reform. This assumption has been signi ® cantly con-® rmed by our research for the case of mandated high-stakes assessment. Two studies were conducted in the two most populous Australian states, New South Wales and Victoria. In the ® nal two years of secondary school in both states, courses of study and assessment arrangements are mandated for all schools, including the private sector, by the state ’ s Board of Studies. Congruence between mandated assessment and school-wide instructional practice was found in two states whose high-stakes assessment embodied quite contrasting values. The assessment agenda Whatever metaphor is employed to characterize the function of assessment within or upon the curriculum, the centrality of assessment is universally acknowledged. This paper makes use of the ® ndings from two related studies to establish and elaborate two fundamental observations regarding the function of assessment:. attempts at curriculum reform are likely to be futile unless accompanied by matching assessment reform; and. assessment can be the engine of curriculum reform, or the prin-cipal impediment to its implementation.

References

6