Fibrillogenesis and Cytotoxic Activity of the Amyloid-forming Apomyoglobin Mutant W7FW14F

Ivana Sirangelo, Clorinda Malmo, Clara Iannuzzi, Antonio Mezzogiorno, Maria Rosaria Bianco, Michèle Papa, Gaetano Irace

Journal of Biological Chemistry · 2004 · 76 citations · 66 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

The apomyoglobin mutant W7FW14F forms amyloid-like fibrils at physiological pH. We examined the kinetics of fibrillogenesis using three techniques: the time dependence of the fluorescence emission of thioflavin T and 1-anilino-8-naphthalenesulfonate, circular dichroism measurements, and electron microscopy. We found that in the early stage of fibril formation, non-native apomyoglobin molecules containing β-structure elements aggregate to form a nucleus. Subsequently, more molecules aggregate around the nucleus, thereby resulting in fibril elongation. We evaluated by MTT assay (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide) the cytotoxicity of these aggregates at the early stage of fibril elongation versus mature fibrils and the wild-type protein. Similar to other amyloid-forming proteins, cell toxicity was not due to insoluble mature fibrils but rather to early pre-fibrillar aggregates. Propidium iodide uptake showed that cell toxicity is the result of altered membrane permeability. Phalloidin staining showed that membrane damage is not associated to an altered cell shape caused by changes in the cytoskeleton. The apomyoglobin mutant W7FW14F forms amyloid-like fibrils at physiological pH. We examined the kinetics of fibrillogenesis using three techniques: the time dependence of the fluorescence emission of thioflavin T and 1-anilino-8-naphthalenesulfonate, circular dichroism measurements, and electron microscopy. We found that in the early stage of fibril formation, non-native apomyoglobin molecules containing β-structure elements aggregate to form a nucleus. Subsequently, more molecules aggregate around the nucleus, thereby resulting in fibril elongation. We evaluated by MTT assay (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide) the cytotoxicity of these aggregates at the early stage of fibril elongation versus mature fibrils and the wild-type protein. Similar to other amyloid-forming proteins, cell toxicity was not due to insoluble mature fibrils but rather to early pre-fibrillar aggregates. Propidium iodide uptake showed that cell toxicity is the result of altered membrane permeability. Phalloidin staining showed that membrane damage is not associated to an altered cell shape caused by changes in the cytoskeleton. Most if not all proteins exist in two structurally different forms, a globular soluble form and an aggregated form that is often produced at extreme temperatures or pH values, at incompatible ionic strength or at a very high protein concentration (1Wetzel R. Trends Biotechnol. 1994; 12: 614-620Abstract Full Full Full Full Full 12: R. Full Full The of protein aggregates and to fibrils Full Full The of soluble globular proteins fibrils is associated the and is not in and the of the is by the of the that in the of rather by the of the that the of globular the the and that the of in an to the protein of insoluble protein aggregates is associated and and these a or protein that is soluble is or in in insoluble fibrils that in or more of to aggregates by and other or a of proteins, to form fibrils that fibrils of by and R. an all forms fibrils containing that the of that of that protein thereby the of the to aggregate R. We that the of the two of and in the of a protein that not R. but aggregates and forms amyloid-like fibrils at physiological pH Full Full protein to of the and at by protein and in cell damage R. Full Full R. R. Full Full that the toxicity of proteins not in the insoluble fibrils but rather in that in the early of fibril R. the of of aggregates of The toxicity of early aggregates to a of of was to the in the of W7FW14F apomyoglobin The toxicity and cell damage by the that form We found that the a non-native different the of protein 1994; other proteins, cell toxicity is not to mature fibrils but to early pre-fibrillar aggregates. the is caused by the cell membrane and permeability. early damage not to changes in the shape of the of cell and W7FW14F mutant and Full Full in forms and The wild-type was in the soluble form and The was by the The W7FW14F mutant was insoluble and was by by pH containing of The pH of the protein was at in the of protein aggregates that by at aggregates of the protein and mature fibrils concentration was and was at and wild-type and mutant The and and was a using that an of The was at using an thioflavin fluorescence was at an of and emission to and emission concentration was an of fluorescence was to at and of and concentration was a of the fluorescence at was by the emission the protein was to the was wild-type and W7FW14F apomyoglobin at a concentration of at a a of the and was at a time and a of of three was all of the not in the and using the by the of the The in of of was the was by electron to and the time of and and and of of protein protein electron and to and a electron at an and in containing and in a at and to the a of The at a of in of MTT assay (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide) and at a of iodide uptake and the cell was containing aggregates and mature fibrils of W7FW14F in to cell at of protein a iodide uptake and staining was by to the in early mature and wild-type and of MTT was to the of of protein of a MTT in to of and was an The was and of MTT by the in at and was by the of protein and was by an of and Phalloidin the different of by in in iodide in in and in in in in and in in and three in in and cell a of a by the of the and Propidium iodide uptake was by fluorescence using a and a and using of of the elements and in a of the the elements and in the staining was to cell The elements or not the of the form is a of that to The more the the circular the and a a form and a form and iodide and staining and to the of was a the pH the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant a soluble to that of the wild-type protein Full Full the and in the the of the is 1994; We the W7FW14F to the and kinetics of fibril by the pH to a and evaluated the fibrillogenesis cell evaluated the pH dependence of apomyoglobin and amyloid-like fibril by the fluorescence emission of two and We to fluorescence to in apomyoglobin the that apomyoglobin high in the by the of the in and fluorescence to to the by the protein the pH is to the is different of the of the that in the form pH the emission of is and to to of non-native protein molecules the 1994; in the emission of the apomyoglobin at pH at is very that to the the wild-type protein the pH the emission of to W7FW14F and was a of the emission the emission of the was the that of in the the pH an of emission of the wild-type protein and a of the emission to a of the of the the of W7FW14F at pH and pH the is of a containing a of the two at and The of by showed the and Full Full The pH to the shape a at that is of a pH caused a of the circular dichroism of apomyoglobin mutant at pH and concentration was of the was T to and is by a of fluorescence at at We examined fluorescence emission in the of the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant at pH to fluorescence was at pH and pH and was at pH We the pH dependence of emission and changes in emission and fluorescence and that the changes by and not by pH dependence of apomyoglobin by fluorescence at and fluorescence The fluorescence at and emission at concentration was and the was was at at and protein concentration was emission was at at pH concentration was a of the emission the of protein to the emission at pH changes in the protein at pH not pH fluorescence was emission was and was a of the emission to of the to the protein. The of fluorescence the of the in the of fluorescence was pH We but the not the protein the shape of the at time not that the pH to of apomyoglobin at pH of was at concentration was and the was and apomyoglobin by fluorescence emission at pH and The to pH to the at pH emission was at at concentration was a of the of the aggregates by W7FW14F at pH using electron staining aggregates by and in globular aggregates and in a early elements globular and very the of fibrils and fibril at and The of these was using Full Full of fibrils was at and and in the The of the aggregated at different time is in apomyoglobin at pH by electron of the at time in a We the of the W7FW14F aggregates and mature versus wild-type The of protein aggregates was by cell membrane and changes that cell The MTT assay is a and of toxicity R. 1994; in MTT in and in the and W7FW14F aggregates of mature fibrils and wild-type apomyoglobin showed that of the cell to aggregates not cell not of W7FW14F apomyoglobin aggregates cell by MTT wild-type apomyoglobin W7FW14F aggregates and W7FW14F mature fibrils of MTT to concentration was aggregates caused a in MTT of membrane the uptake or of molecules or by an and by examined uptake by to early pre-fibrillar aggregates and to mature W7FW14F fibrils Most to pre-fibrillar aggregates The of membrane damage by pre-fibrillar by the was to that of and to mature fibrils very elements is to the cell of of W7FW14F apomyoglobin aggregates cell by iodide cell elements iodide cell elements cell to aggregates high of iodide cell to mature fibrils the iodide The the cell examined cell shape by in the and a very a high of to and to mature fibrils the cell pre-fibrillar aggregates a rather high a of of W7FW14F apomyoglobin aggregates cell shape by cell cell to cell to mature cell fibril is a in protein molecules to form a nucleus. is by fibril in molecules to the nucleus. fibrils Full Full that a in the of proteins and is the of the to a or that Trends Full Full Full Full the fibril is a of protein of of early apomyoglobin is an of fibrillogenesis is soluble at a pH and aggregates at pH or Full Full pH and fluorescence by in the of the apomyoglobin mutant the is by the of pH to fluorescence not but to is that of the is that the wild-type protein showed a of emission and a of the emission that to the by the in the a pH to W7FW14F to a to a to a pH is to is the of apomyoglobin the pH the protein more thereby the in to form fibrils to the of the of apomyoglobin caused by the of and to the to form the wild-type and apomyoglobin in of wild-type and W7FW14F apomyoglobin a R. The the to form of the was found the wild-type W7FW14F that fibril by W7FW14F is a a is by the of fibril was by of to the showed that aggregates and apomyoglobin the early the mutant protein globular that to form that at a in of the of was the that early pre-fibrillar soluble proteins to R. that the forms of and proteins a that is to was by the that an and not soluble of other proteins and R. MTT assay the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant that pre-fibrillar aggregates of proteins to mature fibrils is that early aggregates by and membrane of that W7FW14F apomyoglobin fibrillogenesis and the of is that form in and R. R. is that is a in in the of the W7FW14F apomyoglobin the membrane damage not to the of that a cell Most if not all proteins exist in two structurally different forms, a globular soluble form and an aggregated form that is often produced at extreme temperatures or pH values, at incompatible ionic strength or at a very high protein concentration (1Wetzel R. Trends Biotechnol. 1994; 12: 614-620Abstract Full Full Full Full Full 12: R. Full Full The of protein aggregates and to fibrils Full Full The of soluble globular proteins fibrils is associated the and is not in and the of the is by the of the that in the of rather by the of the that the of globular the the and that the of in an to the protein The of insoluble protein aggregates is associated and and these a or protein that is soluble is or in in insoluble fibrils that in or more of to aggregates by and other or a of proteins, to form fibrils that fibrils of by and R. an all forms fibrils containing that the of that of that protein thereby the of the to aggregate R. We that the of the two of and in the of a protein that not R. but aggregates and forms amyloid-like fibrils at physiological pH Full Full protein to of the and at The by protein and in cell damage R. Full Full R. R. Full Full that the toxicity of proteins not in the insoluble fibrils but rather in that in the early of fibril R. the of of aggregates of The toxicity of early aggregates to a of The of was to the in the of W7FW14F apomyoglobin The toxicity and cell damage by the that form We found that the a non-native different the of protein 1994; other proteins, cell toxicity is not to mature fibrils but to early pre-fibrillar aggregates. the is caused by the cell membrane and permeability. early damage not to changes in the shape of the of cell and W7FW14F mutant and Full Full in forms and The wild-type was in the soluble form and The was by the The W7FW14F mutant was insoluble and was by by pH containing of The pH of the protein was at in the of protein aggregates that by at aggregates of the protein and mature fibrils concentration was and was at and wild-type and mutant The and and was a using that an of The was at using an thioflavin fluorescence was at an of and emission to and emission concentration was an of fluorescence was to at and of and concentration was a of the fluorescence at was by the emission the protein was to the was wild-type and W7FW14F apomyoglobin at a concentration of at a a of the and was at a time and a of of three was all of the not in the and using the by the of the The in of of was the was by electron to and the time of and and and of of protein protein electron and to and a electron at an and in containing and in a at and to the a of The at a of in of MTT assay (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide) and at a of iodide uptake and the cell was containing aggregates and mature fibrils of W7FW14F in to cell at of protein a iodide uptake and staining was by to the in early mature and wild-type and of MTT was to the of of protein of a MTT in to of and was an The was and of MTT by the in at and was by the of protein and was by an of and Phalloidin the different of by in in iodide in in and in in in in and in in and three in in and cell a of a by the of the and Propidium iodide uptake was by fluorescence using a and a and using of of the elements and in a of the the elements and in the staining was to cell The elements or not the of the form is a of that to The more the the circular the and a a form and a form and iodide and staining and to the of was a the and W7FW14F mutant and Full Full in forms and The wild-type was in the soluble form and The was by the The W7FW14F mutant was insoluble and was by by pH containing of The pH of the protein was at in the of protein aggregates that by at aggregates of the protein and mature fibrils concentration was and was at and wild-type and mutant The and and was a using that an of The was at using an thioflavin fluorescence was at an of and emission to and emission concentration was an of fluorescence was to at and of and concentration was a of the fluorescence at was by the emission the protein was to the was wild-type and W7FW14F apomyoglobin at a concentration of at a a of the and was at a time and a of of three was all of the not in the and using the by the of the The in of of was the was by electron to and the time of and and and of of protein protein electron and to and a electron at an and in containing and in a at and to the a of The at a of in of MTT assay (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide) and at a of iodide uptake and the cell was containing aggregates and mature fibrils of W7FW14F in to cell at of protein a iodide uptake and staining was by to the in early mature and wild-type MTT and of MTT was to the of of protein of a MTT in to of and was an The was and of MTT by the in at and was by the of protein and was by an of Propidium and Phalloidin the different of by in in iodide in in and in in in in and in in and three in in and cell a of a by the of the and Propidium iodide uptake was by fluorescence using a and a and using of of the elements and in a of the the elements and in the Phalloidin staining was to cell The elements or not the of the form is a of that to The more the the circular the and a a form and a form and iodide and staining and to the of was a the pH the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant a soluble to that of the wild-type protein Full Full the and in the the of the is 1994; We the W7FW14F to the and kinetics of fibril by the pH to a and evaluated the fibrillogenesis cell evaluated the pH dependence of apomyoglobin and amyloid-like fibril by the fluorescence emission of two and We to fluorescence to in apomyoglobin the that apomyoglobin high in the by the of the in and fluorescence to to the by the protein the pH is to the is different of the of the that in the form pH the emission of is and to to of non-native protein molecules the 1994; in the emission of the apomyoglobin at pH at is very that to the the wild-type protein the pH the emission of to W7FW14F and was a of the emission the emission of the was the that of in the the pH an of emission of the wild-type protein and a of the emission to a of the of the the of W7FW14F at pH and pH the is of a containing a of the two at and The of by showed the and Full Full The pH to the shape a at that is of a pH caused a of the T to and is by a of fluorescence at at We examined fluorescence emission in the of the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant at pH to fluorescence was at pH and pH and was at pH We the pH dependence of emission and changes in emission and fluorescence and that the changes by and not by pH dependence of apomyoglobin by fluorescence at and fluorescence The fluorescence at and emission at concentration was and the was was at at and protein concentration was emission was at at pH concentration was a of the emission the of protein to the emission at pH changes in the protein at pH not pH fluorescence was emission was and was a of the emission to of the to the protein. The of fluorescence the of the in the of fluorescence was pH We but the not the protein the shape of the at time not that the pH to of apomyoglobin at pH of was at concentration was and the was and apomyoglobin by fluorescence emission at pH and The to pH to the at pH emission was at at concentration was a of the of the aggregates by W7FW14F at pH using electron staining aggregates by and in globular aggregates and in a early elements globular and very the of fibrils and fibril at and The of these was using Full Full of fibrils was at and and in the The of the aggregated at different time is in apomyoglobin at pH by electron of the at time in a We the of the W7FW14F aggregates and mature versus wild-type The of protein aggregates was by cell membrane and changes that cell The MTT assay is a and of toxicity R. 1994; in MTT in and in the and W7FW14F aggregates of mature fibrils and wild-type apomyoglobin showed that of the cell to aggregates not cell not of W7FW14F apomyoglobin aggregates cell by MTT wild-type apomyoglobin W7FW14F aggregates and W7FW14F mature fibrils of MTT to concentration was aggregates caused a in MTT of membrane the uptake or of molecules or by an and by examined uptake by to early pre-fibrillar aggregates and to mature W7FW14F fibrils Most to pre-fibrillar aggregates The of membrane damage by pre-fibrillar by the was to that of and to mature fibrils very elements is to the cell of of W7FW14F apomyoglobin aggregates cell by iodide cell elements iodide cell elements cell to aggregates high of iodide cell to mature fibrils the iodide The the cell examined cell shape by in the and a very a high of to and to mature fibrils the cell pre-fibrillar aggregates a rather high a of of W7FW14F apomyoglobin aggregates cell shape by cell cell to cell to mature cell pH the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant a soluble to that of the wild-type protein Full Full the and in the the of the is 1994; We the W7FW14F to the and kinetics of fibril by the pH to a and evaluated the fibrillogenesis cell We evaluated the pH dependence of apomyoglobin and amyloid-like fibril by the fluorescence emission of two and We to fluorescence to in apomyoglobin the that apomyoglobin high in the by the of the in and fluorescence to to the by the protein the pH is to the is different of the of the that in the form pH the emission of is and to to of non-native protein molecules the 1994; in the emission of the apomyoglobin at pH at is very that to the the wild-type protein the pH the emission of to W7FW14F and was a of the emission the emission of the was the that of in the the pH an of emission of the wild-type protein and a of the emission to a of the of the the of W7FW14F at pH and pH the is of a containing a of the two at and The of by showed the and Full Full The pH to the shape a at that is of a pH caused a of the T to and is by a of fluorescence at at We examined fluorescence emission in the of the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant at pH to fluorescence was at pH and pH and was at pH We the pH dependence of emission and changes in emission and fluorescence and that the changes by and not by We the emission at pH changes in the protein at pH not pH fluorescence was emission was and was a of the emission to of the to the protein. The of fluorescence the of the in the of fluorescence was pH We but the not the protein the shape of the at time not that the pH to We the of the aggregates by W7FW14F at pH using electron staining aggregates by and in globular aggregates and in a early elements globular and very the of fibrils and fibril at and The of these was using Full Full of fibrils was at and and in the The of the aggregated at different time is in We the of the W7FW14F aggregates and mature versus wild-type The of protein aggregates was by cell membrane and changes that cell The MTT assay is a and of toxicity R. 1994; in MTT in and in the and W7FW14F aggregates of mature fibrils and wild-type apomyoglobin showed that of the cell to aggregates not cell not of membrane the uptake or of molecules or by an and by examined uptake by to early pre-fibrillar aggregates and to mature W7FW14F fibrils Most to pre-fibrillar aggregates The of membrane damage by pre-fibrillar by the was to that of and to mature fibrils very elements is to the cell of We examined cell shape by in the and a very a high of to and to mature fibrils the cell pre-fibrillar aggregates a rather high a of fibril is a in protein molecules to form a nucleus. is by fibril in molecules to the nucleus. fibrils Full Full that a in the of proteins and is the of the to a or that Trends Full Full Full Full the fibril is a of protein of of early apomyoglobin is an of fibrillogenesis is soluble at a pH and aggregates at pH or Full Full pH and fluorescence by in the of the apomyoglobin mutant the is by the of pH to fluorescence not but to is that of the is that the wild-type protein showed a of emission and a of the emission that to the by the in the a pH to W7FW14F to a to a to a pH is to is the of apomyoglobin the pH the protein more thereby the in to form fibrils to the of the of apomyoglobin caused by the of and to the to form the wild-type and apomyoglobin in that fibril by W7FW14F is a a is by the of fibril was by of to the showed that aggregates and apomyoglobin the early the mutant protein globular that to form that at a in of the of was the that early pre-fibrillar soluble proteins to R. that the forms of and proteins a that is to was by the that an and not soluble of other proteins and R. MTT assay the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant that pre-fibrillar aggregates of proteins to mature fibrils is that early aggregates by and membrane of that W7FW14F apomyoglobin fibrillogenesis and the of is that form in and R. R. is that is a in in the of the W7FW14F apomyoglobin the membrane damage not to the of that a cell fibril is a in protein molecules to form a nucleus. is by fibril in molecules to the nucleus. fibrils Full Full that a in the of proteins and is the of the to a or that Trends Full Full Full Full the fibril is a of protein of of early apomyoglobin is an of fibrillogenesis is soluble at a pH and aggregates at pH or Full Full The pH and fluorescence by in the of the apomyoglobin mutant the is by the of pH to fluorescence not but to is that of the is that the wild-type protein showed a of emission and a of the emission that to the by the in the a pH to W7FW14F to a to a to a pH is to is the of apomyoglobin the pH the protein more thereby the in The to form fibrils to the of the of apomyoglobin caused by the of and to the to form the wild-type and apomyoglobin in that fibril by W7FW14F is a a is by the of fibril was by of to the showed that aggregates and apomyoglobin the early the mutant protein globular that to form that at a in of the of was the that early pre-fibrillar soluble proteins to R. that the forms of and proteins a that is to was by the that an and not soluble of other proteins and R. MTT assay the W7FW14F apomyoglobin mutant that pre-fibrillar aggregates of proteins to mature fibrils is that early aggregates by and membrane of that W7FW14F apomyoglobin fibrillogenesis and the of is that form in and R. R. is that is a in in the of the W7FW14F apomyoglobin the membrane damage not to the of that a cell We to the

References

66