The Convention on the Rights of the Child: What it Means for Children in War

Ilene Cohn

International Journal of Refugee Law · 1991 · 26 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Children are increasingly both victims and refugees from war and hostilities, and this article aims to provide information of help to children's rights advocates, in the better protection of the rights of children and refugee and displaced children. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) raises important questions of interpretation, and it is crucial to understand how the full range of human rights and humanitarian principles can be used to best effect. The CRC is important for children in war situations, because it includes elements of international humanitarian law, in particular, the obligation on States Parties to take all feasible measures to ensure that persons under the age of fifteen do not take a direct part in hostilities, and refrain from recruiting persons under fifteen. These and related provisions are considered, together with other international standards, such as those in the 1949 Geneva Conventions and the 1977 Additional Protocols. The fifteen year age limit was controversial during negotiations, as was the qualifying language of obligation. Attempts to secure a higher age failed, and other concerns remain, such as the overall applicability of the CRC and its relationship with other international instruments. The author argues that it might provide an informal point of entry for international humanitarian obligations, particularly for States which have not ratified the Additional Protocols. The author also notes that certain rights with respect to deprivation of liberty, education, or the cultural, linguistic and religious rights of indigenous minorities, are more extensive in the CRC, than in the Geneva Conventions and Protocols, whereas other international human rights instruments include provisions that remain in force in war-time, and offer even greater protection. The CRC also offers potential for the protection of refugee children. Its breadth of application means that it is not dependent upon lawful or other status, and it offers greater protection in several important instances, such as economic, social, cultural, civil and political rights, the right to a name and a nationality immediately after birth, and the right to preservation of identity. In other circumstances, however, higher standards in other treaties must be relied on. The author concludes by recommending that non-governmental organizations have an important role to play, if the proposed Committee on the Rights of the Child is to be effective. NGOs are well placed to provide data on how children are affected by policy, and on their needs; they should not miss the opportunity