Journal of Biological Chemistry · 2005 · 68 citations · 24 references
Life SciencesBiochemistryMolecular BiologyEnzymologyProtein BiochemistryStructural BiologyEnzyme StabilityLipid OxidationProtein OxidationProtein StructureStructural EnzymologyCholesterol StructureCholesterol-protein InteractionsDenaturationFlavin CofactorsMelting Temperature AnalysisProtein UnfoldingTertiary Structure DisruptionThermal Denaturation Studies
Cholesterol oxidase from Brevibacterium sterolicum is a monomeric flavoenzyme catalyzing the oxidation and isomerization of cholesterol to cholest-4-en-3-one. This protein is a class II cholesterol oxidases, with the FAD cofactor covalently linked to the enzyme through the His69 residue. In this work, unfolding of wild-type cholesterol oxidase was compared with that of a H69A mutant, which does not covalently bind the flavin cofactor. The two protein forms do not show significant differences in their overall topology, but the urea-induced unfolding of the H69A mutant occurred at significant lower urea concentrations than wild-type (∼3 versus ∼5 m, respectively), and the mutant protein had a melting temperature ∼10–15 °C lower than wild-type in thermal denaturation experiments. The different sensitivity of the various spectroscopic features used to monitor protein unfolding indicated that in both proteins a two-step (three-state) process occurs. The presence of an intermediate was more evident for the H69A mutant at 2 m urea, where catalytic activity and tertiary structure were lost, and new hydrophobic patches were exposed on the protein surface, resulting in protein aggregation. Comparative analysis of the changes occurring upon urea and thermal treatment of the wild-type and H69A protein showed a good correlation between protein instability and the elimination of the covalent link between the flavin and the protein. This covalent bond represents a structural device to modify the flavin redox potentials and stabilize the tertiary structure of cholesterol oxidase, thus pointing to a specific meaning of the flavin binding mode in enzymes that carry out the same reaction in pathogenic versus non-pathogenic bacteria. Cholesterol oxidase from Brevibacterium sterolicum is a monomeric flavoenzyme catalyzing the oxidation and isomerization of cholesterol to cholest-4-en-3-one. This protein is a class II cholesterol oxidases, with the FAD cofactor covalently linked to the enzyme through the His69 residue. In this work, unfolding of wild-type cholesterol oxidase was compared with that of a H69A mutant, which does not covalently bind the flavin cofactor. The two protein forms do not show significant differences in their overall topology, but the urea-induced unfolding of the H69A mutant occurred at significant lower urea concentrations than wild-type (∼3 versus ∼5 m, respectively), and the mutant protein had a melting temperature ∼10–15 °C lower than wild-type in thermal denaturation experiments. The different sensitivity of the various spectroscopic features used to monitor protein unfolding indicated that in both proteins a two-step (three-state) process occurs. The presence of an intermediate was more evident for the H69A mutant at 2 m urea, where catalytic activity and tertiary structure were lost, and new hydrophobic patches were exposed on the protein surface, resulting in protein aggregation. Comparative analysis of the changes occurring upon urea and thermal treatment of the wild-type and H69A protein showed a good correlation between protein instability and the elimination of the covalent link between the flavin and the protein. This covalent bond represents a structural device to modify the flavin redox potentials and stabilize the tertiary structure of cholesterol oxidase, thus pointing to a specific meaning of the flavin binding mode in enzymes that carry out the same reaction in pathogenic versus non-pathogenic bacteria. Bacterial cholesterol oxidase (CO, EC 1.1.3.6) is a monomeric bifunctional FAD-containing flavoenzyme that catalyzes the oxidation of 3β-hydroxysteroids and the isomerization of the intermediate, Δ5–6-ene-3β-ketosteroid (cholest-5-en-3-one) to produce Δ3–4-ene-3β-ketosteroid (cholest-4-en-3-one). Bacteria that produce CO can be classified into two classes: non-pathogenic (e.g. Streptomyces and fast-growing Mycobacteria; these bacteria utilize cholesterol as their carbon source) and pathogenic bacteria (e.g. Rhodococcus equi and slow-growing Mycobacteria). Pathogenic bacteria require CO for infection of the host macrophage probably because of its ability to alter the physical structure of the membrane by converting cholesterol into cholest-4-en-3-one. The crystal structure of COs belonging to two distinct structural classes (1Sampson N.S. Vrielink A. Acc. Chem. Res. 2003; 36: 713-722Crossref PubMed Scopus (54) Google Scholar) have been solved by the Vrielink laboratory (2Vrielink A. Lloyd L.F. Blow D.M. J. Mol. Biol. 1991; 219: 533-554Crossref PubMed Scopus (191) Google Scholar, 3Yue K.Q. Kass I.J. Sampson N.S. Vrielink A. Biochemistry. 1999; 38: 4277-4286Crossref PubMed Scopus (111) Google Scholar, 4Coulombe R. Yue K.Q. Ghisla Vrielink A. J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google classified as as from Streptomyces and R. equi J. J. J. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar) have their cofactor but to the CO from Brevibacterium sterolicum classified as is In this enzyme the cofactor is covalently linked to the protein a bond between the of the and the of COs of class and II the same catalytic show in the flavin binding and have significant differences in their redox and Ghisla J. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, Ghisla J. 1999; PubMed Scopus Google proteins to their and to have been to flavin covalently linked to a N.S. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, PubMed Scopus Google The redox of the flavin through a specific protein to the of the redox on the mutant of oxidase that covalent flavin binding the structural of the enzyme PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google The covalent CO to the of oxidase J. A. PubMed Scopus Google which a to covalent the of covalent flavin in this a mutant in which the His69 of the bond to the and this to in the Ghisla J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google The mutant catalytic activity and out the isomerization of the intermediate to the but the flavin binding in a in and in a lower flavin redox compared with for that the flavin to a is a in the of the redox of this CO to its Ghisla J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google In of the is in this CO is used for cholesterol in the of and J. J. Mol. Biol. PubMed Scopus Google CO is a and been as an PubMed Scopus Google CO by that have been to a in the of and to the in and J. J. PubMed Scopus Google In R. equi is an in in as these enzymes to a for a new class of In the of a to the analysis of flavoenzyme structure and CO from sterolicum as a for protein and binding The for the protein been and can be in the structure of the wild-type enzyme is R. Yue K.Q. Ghisla Vrielink A. J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar) and that of the H69A mutant been In this the of the covalent link of the flavin cofactor on the and process of and and were from were of the and H69A COs were from was the and for H69A and wild-type at Ghisla J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google oxidase activity was at in an with and as Ghisla J. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, Ghisla J. 1999; PubMed Scopus Google activity was in and at The of urea on enzyme activity was the same on protein at °C for in the presence of various and were with a in at and protein at were in a with a a were from to of were from to an of were used for and were at °C in at protein were by the of the were a temperature which at the same temperature used in and were at and for and flavin were on a with a temperature and by of was for and for in the and H69A COs were at °C in with in the presence of an urea at which the intermediate is and 2 m for wild-type and mutant protein at various the of were in for and for were with and the of the protein were by analysis for protein were to a a of and COs was at temperature on a the at a of The was m The was with of was in an protein were out on protein in in was which is for of in the temperature from to of and were were by of the J. 38: Scopus Google The the between the of the and the of the was the temperature was to Scopus Google Scholar) by of in the for where is the temperature at which the protein is The overall denaturation was by of the denaturation where is the temperature of the denaturation into that the a the same temperature a can be by a to the from the and the overall process J. 38: Scopus Google a of the a through and was used as the the in this were of the presence of the which to the on from to the the was by a and was not into The and a of and of the The used to the were through the and used The unfolding of CO was by the changes in flavin and protein as as in and as the to the was as a of changes at in urea denaturation was on by of a protein m urea in and binding were out at °C and at protein unfolding protein were for at °C in different concentrations of urea, and was to a of were in the an of the wild-type and H69A COs were at various concentrations of urea for at °C and were by in at The was by protein and flavin the for the and enzymes as and by the of activity with to the protein Ghisla J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google the unfolding were a unfolding for the were to the of the the Chem. is the and and the for the and The in between the and the was by the is the is the and is the The were the of unfolding to be on the urea by PubMed Scopus Google and the of unfolding in the and presence of urea, is the of urea for unfolding m for the of the unfolding at analysis was used to the of m, and by a wild-type and H69A COs were as significant differences in their because of the different binding mode of the flavin cofactor Ghisla J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google In in to the at of and for H69A and wild-type respectively), the mutant CO a at and the in the of the wild-type to protein the two CO at an at and for wild-type and H69A with a for H69A than for wild-type a different of between and in the two The of the FAD cofactor at is different for the two CO The is at and for wild-type and H69A and the of flavin is for the mutant protein. The lower of the wild-type protein at with to the H69A mutant from of the which in a in flavin J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Google Scholar, R. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar) and in the on the of CO used R. PubMed Scopus Google both unfolding by urea is by an in both flavin and had in the two proteins wild-type CO does not the flavin which is covalently linked to and thus the flavin in the protein does not to that of the as is the for the H69A is lower in wild-type CO with to that of the of wild-type and H69A CO not in the features to the structure of the two differences evident in the (e.g. at for the H69A mutant and at for the wild-type pointing to a of the tertiary structure in the mutant as indicated by the protein the of m urea, the in the and of both wild-type and H69A CO were The of wild-type and H69A CO was by unfolding by different spectroscopic and the catalytic activity in the presence of urea of was used as of the protein in CO the overall changes in of changes in protein urea the two CO forms showed a different in the of the protein that was at m urea of urea the of to from for wild-type and for H69A CO to at m urea, a that for both enzyme forms the in The is a of the of to a more upon protein unfolding N.S. PubMed Scopus Google of changes in the of protein at as a of the urea a The of was to The of unfolding in the of the can be by of to both changes in the of at urea concentrations were different from of protein and occurred at lower urea concentrations of and m for wild-type and H69A This that the overall urea-induced denaturation of CO be a more pointing to the presence of unfolding of for urea-induced unfolding of wild-type and H69A COs at by of protein and flavin at and and by at and from the of catalytic from the of catalytic at from the of catalytic at in a new urea concentrations had a different on flavin in the two of the H69A mutant at urea concentrations the for protein and and and to that of the flavin at m both protein and flavin of a process for both and do not for an unfolding The of urea concentrations on the protein and flavin of wild-type and H69A CO was at where the enzymes their catalytic activity in in the in in a of the unfolding for wild-type unfolding of the H69A mutant was to a more urea-induced of structural was by the changes in at the of wild-type and H69A CO showed a different sensitivity to the of the at a of urea m for the mutant but at m urea for of urea a different on the tertiary structure of wild-type and H69A as by the in at in In both a was to in protein and flavin the to of the and tertiary and a of the overall protein structure because of of the protein into an a was at lower concentrations for mutant than for wild-type hydrophobic was used to the of hydrophobic in CO at urea of this to of in proteins in a in its and is by a in its The of in the presence of both CO forms in their that hydrophobic patches exposed in both proteins in The of hydrophobic upon of the protein tertiary structure the unfolding process was by the binding of to the two CO forms at urea both proteins were with in the presence of various urea of the in at the for and the between these two A. J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google of the for binding to wild-type CO at urea concentrations the with the urea a at m urea and that hydrophobic were exposed in wild-type CO at m were with H69A urea concentrations to 2 m the for binding to respectively), with a and significant in in urea concentrations in a in and in an in m urea both to of wild-type CO and This that the unfolding intermediate for the H69A mutant at m urea a hydrophobic with to wild-type hydrophobic were in the of protein at m In of the of at was in and concentrations not were evident for the H69A an in to m urea was by a in the to at m and a in the to were at urea and were at m In the mutant a of at urea the in the of enzyme activity and the changes in the of of protein at urea of a in the was at urea concentrations with for unfolding by flavin and protein and by in the different these that hydrophobic were exposed in the of the urea-induced and that these as urea concentrations to flavin from a H69A protein. the urea on of wild-type CO and showed a different probably because of the different of with a protein in which the flavin cofactor is The with the mutant enzyme was the of a in the of at m This to the for wild-type CO the of the activity and activity is a for the changes in protein as the at the The of urea on the activity of CO was by the enzyme activity on protein for the to at °C in the presence of different in the enzyme activity of wild-type CO to at m urea and is at m urea, the activity of the mutant protein was at m The from activity were lower than that for and were to for the in binding that the of catalytic activity the of the to the of both enzyme forms and of wild-type CO in at The protein as a monomeric in the of urea as an at 2 m urea as a of and forms at m urea and and as at m urea and the intermediate from and at m urea an of had a lower than as evident by the in the overall that at m urea was of that at m The H69A mutant in the of urea had an to that of wild-type CO at 2 m urea as a of and forms and and as a at m the of the H69A mutant at the urea to the of the intermediate evident by binding was compared with the protein in the of protein from for the mutant and from wild-type at urea concentrations m, a the FAD cofactor was at of the of wild-type and H69A CO was by the of activity and the of changes in and flavin a in of the proteins urea both a of the changes in and flavin upon was in the of the by and In the to for the urea for both CO The of the in flavin was the and was not in reaction a that this is than the the at urea were than protein unfolding at the same urea This that the the process was the same were in the of oxidase, a FAD-containing a flavin A. J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google CO enzymes of the specific activity unfolding with a of urea at which of the activity was and m, for wild-type and H69A and by and for at of the enzyme activity was from m wild-type and H69A these show that the urea-induced unfolding of wild-type and H69A CO is at in of their overall tertiary but the and COs in the the flavin which in their have been to have on the changes from the elimination of the covalent link between the and the analysis of the of of wild-type and H69A CO showed that both enzyme forms were into two of and The of the to that of CO at the of the at The of the was in good with the for the and that of the with that of the to the of the was for wild-type of H69A was both the of the two from on at that these were were on the that both were of The from of the forms of both H69A and wild-type CO treatment with was to that of the protein. a enzyme in which the The activity of H69A and wild-type COs from was and of that of the for protein of and for wild-type and H69A as by that the of both COs is of the CO structure R. Yue K.Q. Ghisla Vrielink A. J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar) that the to in the enzyme is on the protein and to the which is a structural of the and is not in with the flavin cofactor. in this a temperature was of for to the R. Yue K.Q. Ghisla Vrielink A. J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google of both wild-type and H69A CO was at urea concentrations at which the unfolding intermediate is and 2 m, of the proteins was than (e.g. H69A CO was in than at this of unfolding of both proteins was at In the presence of m urea, wild-type CO was into the and in the of the H69A mutant in the presence of 2 m urea for at and in to of the various from of H69A CO indicated two specific in to that at in the at and at the and The of at in the mutant is to the in this protein and for covalent binding of the flavin cofactor in wild-type CO and were to the temperature sensitivity of both and specific structural features in wild-type and H69A and to unfolding can be upon as to the spectroscopic and protein were the same used for urea sensitivity to be that in protein were the of a for the of these as by the various were ∼10–15 °C for wild-type than for H69A CO II and of structure was by the at were to for FAD as in on the temperature sensitivity of as a of tertiary structure the different of the two CO and lower than by flavin and structure hydrophobic of the protein had a temperature sensitivity than as indicated by the in and binding experiments. In these an in the as a of that for the at at the of of the CO This temperature is a of the of protein as in where was used to monitor thermal protein unfolding J. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, J. Chem. Scopus Google of as by different on wild-type and H69A mutant of overall in a new In of the temperature of spectroscopic were out the of protein with the of as for CO a in at protein were evident in a of out in and at a of as for the spectroscopic In these the unfolding for both proteins was to a of R. R. J. PubMed Scopus Google the were The in showed a for that of the as with flavin A. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google and the of protein the unfolding of of CO at of the of the as indicated by the in the presence of urea in a different of this The binding in a a of exposed hydrophobic in the CO as for proteins J. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, J. Chem. Scopus Google in were by the to where both CO forms catalytic the in a distinct temperature with to the unfolding as in for both forms of The of at was for wild-type CO to as compared with to °C for the H69A both the from to not the of the the unfolding of the their This that for these proteins is at not be to a on that were The were by the to resulting in the in which for the different thermal of the two were for wild-type and mutant CO and respectively), but were lower for the H69A than for wild-type CO versus that different of the two proteins is because of In the of wild-type were not at as by a the the for the H69A mutant were and The of the analysis to a in which thermal denaturation be because of J. and of Scholar, A. J. PubMed Scopus Google The and for °C and °C and °C and for the and In the of the mutant where was to carry out a analysis of the to the in thermal denaturation is the had a temperature with the of structure and cofactor as for flavin A. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google the with this were to for the of structural that the of flavin in a mutant of a oxidase and °C for the versus and °C for H69A A. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google in tertiary structure hydrophobic of the protein be to occurring at lower in H69A In is a between the for the two and and the for of of tertiary structure and for of hydrophobic a analysis of the for wild-type CO was not for the the in II evident that the temperature sensitivity of in this the same for the mutant but these in a temperature in the wild-type protein versus This both a of the wild-type and a of in its of the two CO forms in the Ghisla J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google as as in their and flavin and in their in wild-type and H69A with the sensitivity to and the of denaturation that wild-type and H69A CO do not show significant differences in their overall The differences in the proteins be of changes in the the flavin cofactor the of the covalent link to as indicated by the in the redox of the that in the catalytic activity Ghisla J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google The of and H69A evident from the is that the covalent link of the flavin cofactor to the the structural of CO and thermal spectroscopic showed that the urea for the unfolding of the CO mutant FAD was lower than that of the wild-type and that different urea concentrations were for unfolding of protein. The two proteins showed a °C in the temperature of to their thermal Comparative analysis of the changes in the structural and of the two CO forms upon of urea thermal treatment a good correlation between the of to the elimination of the covalent link between the flavin cofactor and the and protein The urea-induced unfolding of both wild-type and H69A CO can be as a two-step (three-state) The presence of in the unfolding process was by the different urea sensitivity of the various protein features used to monitor the of changes in and of and were of a as were the of evident by thermal denaturation spectroscopic and the by unfolding of both COs was at urea concentrations m, at which the changes were and as were at a two as the urea is of the tertiary structure and of hydrophobic at urea by unfolding to of the cofactor at urea The from a does not from the different of the cofactor in wild-type and H69A because unfolding have been both proteins at lower urea concentrations at lower for the mutant a of of a and that the is the same for the in the the in to the of of the In not as a of a because this is as a of the between the of urea in the and This is not the with the H69A of that the the overall protein structure to a This is by the temperature of the different thermal unfolding in the mutant compared with wild-type the that the intermediate by urea to a that to a with structure but not tertiary in which hydrophobic exposed to The of intermediate the unfolding process was in the H69A denaturation show that H69A CO its activity and of its tertiary structure at 2 m urea, where of the structure and FAD binding were binding and that the unfolding intermediate had exposed new hydrophobic patches on that were for of the protein. The at 2 m urea of the spectroscopic features in H69A CO at between and of the unfolding intermediate in denaturation for both CO forms is a as from activity activity can be from in the flavin binding and the of the enzyme activity of structural differences between the and the and the of on the that the occurring unfolding than to the of the unfolding intermediate and to the of the the of both CO forms was that the intermediate of of the protein denaturation been for enzymes A. PubMed Scopus Google and and for a of proteins J. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, J. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google The of these proteins be to the of hydrophobic as by binding that hydrophobic between belonging to distinct urea the of urea the structure and to an and protein the temperature of the as for proteins J. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, J. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google the CO a monomeric of from which an hydrophobic of is to a of the the a was at the of the that the enzyme structure is of and and can be into two R. Yue K.Q. Ghisla Vrielink A. J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google a and a The of the that of a of which is by oxidase J. A. PubMed Scopus Google The to be specific for because structural not in The of CO is a a of by the of the cofactor on and by a of the on the in the and and between and show temperature and have been to as the The of at is on the of these two The in this that the of the is the more in both wild-type and H69A protein forms is from the and that the overall protein is the elimination of the covalent link with flavin cofactor. The of for wild-type CO was at m urea, a at which the of the protein to that of the unfolding intermediate in the the the unfolding intermediate of H69A CO at 2 m urea showed two of both belonging to the The is at the of the that the of is in bond with the of the as for oxidase J. A. PubMed Scopus Google The is of the and is on the 2 and The of these as as the is not in wild-type and H69A the flavin to the protein in CO be as a structural device that of the overall tertiary structure of the protein by the of the structural between the two at the protein structure as a of be that In the of this covalent the denaturation process is and at lower temperature and urea This is evident by the temperature for thermal denaturation of the H69A mutant versus wild-type and by the presence of in the unfolding intermediate of the H69A protein. The of the of because from a structural is a of the oxidase of J. A. PubMed Scopus Google the process of CO a as for the that the of covalent that COs a covalently linked cofactor enzymes in the of COs FAD in In this the covalent flavin bond in sterolicum CO is an in the redox of the protein its ability Ghisla J. Biol. Chem. PubMed Scopus Google and thus its to alter the structure of the membrane in the in a of its the the in protein is in in The reaction is in a of and a at the structural of the of these enzymes from an for the with protein
24
Savitzky-Golay Smoothing Filters
William H. Press, Saul A. Teukolsky · Computers in Physics · 1990 · 11.8K citations · Full text