Building for Freshman Success: High Schools Working as Professional Learning Communities

Julie D. McIntosh, Sandra White

American secondary education · 2006 · 48 citations · 3 references

Concepts

Abstract

ABSTRACT A pivotal point for students is the transition from middle school to high school. Students will decide during the first few weeks of their year if they intend to continue their high school education (Hertzog & Morgan, 1999). This article provides the reader with the research surrounding this transition year, programs and practices that have been successful, and the impact the freshman wing concept has had on a large, comprehensive high school in Findlay, Ohio. CREATING THE PERFECT SCHOOL WHERE NO CHILD IS LEFT BEHIND Creating the perfect school environment that ensures academic, social, and emotional success for every student is foremost in every administrator's mind and heart. This was true even before No Child Left Behind became the law of the land. But how does one do this, especially at pivotal transition times in a student's life? How to make the critical transition between middle school and high school successful was a question that plagued Findlay High School (FHS) administrators for years. School data reflected that a majority (71%) of our freshmen were making a successful transition to high school; however, 29% of our students were failing one or more classes. Success or failure during the year sets the tone for a student's entire high school career (Hertzog & Morgan, 1999). If a student is successful during that year, there is a great likelihood that the student will not only graduate from high school but will also enjoy the high school experience. The converse is also true. If a student does not have a good experience that year, the decision to drop out of high school is either consciously or subconsciously made at that time. EXAMPLES OF TRANSITION PROGRAMS Research has provided educators with many alternatives to increase student achievement. One model, a school-within-a-school, may be called a learning community, a cluster, or an academy. In large schools, this model can help downsize the number of students to a manageable student population for teachers and administrators. Some positive impacts of downsizing are improvements in attendance, student achievement, behavior, attainment, teacher morale, and parental contact (DeWees, 1999). A critical success factor is the commitment to implementation. Some disadvantages to this model are that it can create divisive rivalries or fracture existing relationships. The divisiveness comes from separating teachers into teams. Conflicts can develop from the commitment a teacher feels toward the school versus the smaller unit that can lead to rivalries (DeWees, 1999). Teachers begin to worry about how they can move from one school to another or that they will not gain autonomy (Gewertz, 2001). The mechanics of how a team operates is critical to the implementation of learning communities, clusters or academies. Hertzog and Morgan (1999) suggested creating a grade that can assist students making the transition from middle school to high school. [They also found that make the decision to continue their high school education in the first few weeks of this critical transition stage]. In order to reduce stress in this transition, ninth grade programs can help students acclimate to their surroundings. Having a ninth grade house also benefits teachers who can specialize in working with this age group. The schedule increases teacher contact with the ninth grade population, and teaming of ninth grade teachers can help monitor student success. Development of these teams can decrease failures and dropout rates. Hertzog and Morgan (1999) surveyed 97 middle schools and 56 high schools in Georgia and Florida to determine what transition programs were in place. A control group that had two or fewer transition practices was compared to schools that had three or more transition practices. The researchers found that schools with two or fewer transition practices had higher attrition and drop out rates than those with three or more transition practices. …

References

3