The Importance of High School Quality in University Admissions Decisions.

Mo‐Yin S. Tam, Uday Sukhatme

College and university · 2003 · 12 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Abstract The authors studied the student pipeline at the University of Illinois at Chicago over a period of six years to pinpoint which attributes of entering students provide the best indicators of university success. They found that the best indicator is a modified high school percentile rank, designed specifically to take high school quality into account. Although urban public universities enjoy many benefits based on their special locations, they generally suffer from substantially lower graduation rates as compared to their non-urban counterparts. This lowers the rankings of urban public universities in comparative studies such as those made annually in U.S. News & World Report. This, in turn, makes it harder for these institutions to hire talented faculty and to attract top quality students (U.S. News and World Report Online 2001). Furthermore, admitting students who do not succeed wastes limited educational resources. It is clear that most urban public universities need to make considerable improvements in their admission and retention efforts. In order to do this, it is essential to determine which freshman student attributes provide the best indicators of subsequent university success in the urban university setting. The authors' analysis is carried out using data from the University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC), with a careful study of the student pipeline over a period of six years. Although the conclusions drawn are based on UIC data, it is reasonable to apply the results to other urban public universities with a dominant commuter student body similar to UIC. More specifically, the authors made an in-depth analysis on a cohort of 2,529 freshmen who entered UIC in Fall 1994. This choice was necessary in order to examine the six-year graduation rate. UIC has a relatively low six-year graduation rate of about 36 percent, and will clearly benefit from a better understanding of the attributes of both successful and unsuccessful students. It was studied in detail how success is related to four quantitative, quasi-continuous, input attributes that characterize new students: A measure of school quality was incorporated into the new variable HSPR* by including the HSACT factor. The authors also studied student performance as a function of the four input variables and their linear combinations in order to pinpoint the best indicator of success at UIC. The analysis was then repeated with subsets, obtained by making various choices of discrete characteristics like gender [male, female] and race/ethnicity [Latino, Black, Asian, White]. This permitted the authors to examine the dependence of success at UIC on gender and race. It should be noted that other input variables and their predictive capabilities for university success have been examined by several authors. These include studies of the academic rigor of a student's high school program (Young and Barrett 1992), academic records (Touron 1983), mathematics testing (Haeck, Yeld, Conradie, Robertson, and Shall 1997), and district performance indices (Bennett, Wesley and Dana-Wesley 1999). In fact, at this time, there is considerable pressure for higher education to find new ways of assessing the fitness of high school students for college study (Stern and Briggs 2001). Overall Pipeline The overall pipeline showing the time evolution of the 2,529 freshmen that entered UIC in Fall 1994 is given in Table 1 and graphed in Figure 1. Table 1 shows as a function of time the percentage of students who continue to remain enrolled at UIC, those who graduate, those who drop out in poor academic standing, and those who drop out in good standing. At UIC, grades are given on a 5-point scale, and students who leave in good or poor standing are those who leave with a cumulative GPA > or = 3.0 or a cumulative GPA