Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy · 2023 · 13 citations · 22 references
EducationCounselingPsychologyClinical PsychologyCounseling PsychologyPsychotherapyBehavior TherapyCognitive Behavioral TherapyCounseling InterventionsTreatment Of Mental DisordersBig Five Personality ModelBig Five Personality TraitsExperimental Study DesignFeedbackFeedback InterventionsPsychotherapy Outcome MeasurementTreatment Outcome AnalysisTreatment Outcome Monitoring
Although studies have shown that client feedback can improve treatment outcome, little is known about which factors might possibly moderate the effects of such feedback. The present study investigated potential therapist variables that might influence whether frequent client feedback is effective, including the Big Five personality traits, internal/external feedback propensity and self-efficacy. Data from two previous studies, a quasi-experimental study and a randomized controlled trial, were combined. The sample consisted of 38 therapists and 843 clients (55.4% females, mean age = 42.05 years, SD = 11.75) from an outpatient mental health institution. The control condition consisted of cognitive-behavioural therapies combined with low frequency monitoring of clients' symptoms. In the experimental condition, high-intensity (i.e., frequent) client feedback as an add-on to treatment as usual was provided. Outcomes were measured as adjusted post-treatment symptom severity on the Symptom Checklist-90 and drop out from treatment. The final model of the multilevel analyses showed that therapists with higher levels of self-efficacy had poorer treatment outcomes, but when high-intensity client feedback was provided, their effectiveness improved. Furthermore, higher self-efficacy was associated with a higher estimation of therapists' own effectiveness, but therapists' self-assessment of effectiveness was not correlated with their actual effectiveness. The results of this study might indicate that therapists with high levels of self-efficacy benefit from client feedback because it can correct their biases. However, for therapists with low self-efficacy, client feedback might be less beneficial, possibly because it can make them more insecure. These hypotheses need to be investigated in future research.
22
Sufficient Sample Sizes for Multilevel Modeling
Cora J. M. Maas, Joop J. Hox · Methodology · 2005 · 3.4K citations
An Investigation of Self-Assessment Bias in Mental Health Providers
Steven Walfish, Brian McAlister, Ed O’Donnell et al. · Psychological Reports · 2012 · 385 citations