Beyond managerialism?

Rick Delbridge, Tom Keenoy

The International Journal of Human Resource Management · 2010 · 163 citations · 36 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Critics of HRM, including those from Critical Management Studies and mainstream scholars, argue that mainstream HRM is moribund and limited, and that Critical Human Resource Management seeks to contextualize HRM within capitalism, challenge managerialist assumptions, and amplify voices of workers, minorities, non‑standard employees, trade unions, and others outside large Western corporations. The article seeks to define Critical Human Resource Management and argues that incorporating its diverse methodological and theoretical approaches will enrich HRM research by broadening settings and questions. CHRM is analytically coherent through a theorization of the employment relationship that acknowledges sociological, psychological, economic, political, and ethical aspects of work, management, and organization. The authors find that productive interaction between CHRM and mainstream HRM is unlikely until mainstream HRM critically evaluates rather than assumes the managerial perspective.

Abstract

This article addresses the question of what might constitute Critical Human Resource Management (CHRM). Consideration is given to ideas from critics of HRM, both from within the field and those external to it, in particular Critical Management Studies, and to mainstream scholars who have voiced concerns regarding the moribund and limited nature of mainstream HRM. CHRM is advanced in order that HRM might be better contextualized within the prevailing socio-economic order of capitalism; managerialist assumptions and language may be denaturalized and challenged; and that voices excluded in mainstream HRM, such as workers (especially minorities and those in non-standard employment), trade unions and those involved outside large Western corporations, may be heard. The analytical coherence of CHRM builds from a theorization of the employment relationship and requires acknowledgement of the sociological, psychological, economic, political and ethical aspects of working, managing and organizing. In our view, HRM research will be enriched by the variety of methodological and theoretical approaches of CHRM and by the inclusion of a wider range of different research settings and research questions. However, a fruitful and reflexive engagement between CHRM and mainstream HRM seems unlikely until the latter critically assesses rather than assumes the managerial perspective.

References

36