Journal of Small Business Management · 1994 · 37 citations · 0 references
ManagementStrategic ManagementStrategyCorporate StrategyStrategic Decision-makingStrategic PlanningCorporate Strategy AnalysisStrategy FormulationFirm PerformanceSmall Business PerformanceSmall Business PolicyStrategic PlanStrategic Planning Process
For many years strategic management/business policy researchers have attempted to learn why some small enterprises achieve higher levels of performance than others. Much of the empirical research concerning strategic management in small firms has emphasized strategic planning (Bahaee 1987; Bracker, Keats, and Pearson 1988; Orpen 1985; Robinson 1980; Robinson and Pearce 1983; Sexton and Van Auken 1982). What these researchers failed to recognize is that planning is only one aspect of the strategic management process (Rhyne 1986). Another aspect, which is seldom studied (even in large businesses), is the implementation of strategic decisions. The development and selection of strategies to pursue is considered easier and less time-consuming than implementing those strategies once they have been chosen (David 1989, Jauch and Glueck 1988, Thompson and Strickland 1987). While Thompson and Strickland (1987) suggest that strategy implementation is probably five to ten times more time consuming than formulating the strategic plan, Jauch and Glueck (1988) report that executive investment in implementation has been insufficient. A recent study examined a large number of corporate strategy articles appearing in a leading business periodical and found that only 14 of 33 strategies detailed in those articles succeeded (Business Week 1984). Several previous studies have also reported implementation failures (Bardach 1977, Pressman and Wildavsky 1973, Schultz and Slevin 1975). This article reports on the implementation of strategic decisions in a number of small, commercial North Carolina Banks. These strategic decisions are similar to those made by other types of small businesses. Small bank strategic decisions are, however, disparately affected by the large amount of capital required for start-up and operations as well as the constraints levied on banks by the federal and state governments. This study found that small banks which experience fewer problems during a strategic-decision implementation process are more successful than those which have to resolve more of these problems. Bank presidents' self-reported effective implementation was our measure of success. REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE Poor implementation of an appropriate strategy can result in the failure of that strategy. A good implementation plan, however, will not only ensure the success of an appropriate strategy, it can also redeem a less appropriate strategy (Wheelan and Hunger 1991). This is why an increasing number of chief executives are turning their attention to the problems of implementation. Among other things, they now realize that a successful strategy depends on having in place the right organizational structures, well-designed compensation programs, and effective resource allocations, information systems, and corporate cultures (Galbraith and Kazanjian 1986, Miesing 1984). Support for this trend has come from a recent study of companies in 31 U.S. manufacturing industries in which it was revealed that firm performance is not so much a result of a company's strategy, but of its capacity to implement that strategy effectively (Lawless, Bergh, and Wilsted 1989). Strategic management techniques used in other industries are not new to the banking industry, and, over the years, use of these techniques has intensified, not diminished. Earlier, Olson (1964) and Hegazy (1965) found that profit-planning techniques and other long-range planning frequently used in other industries (mainly manufacturing) could also be applied to commercial banking. Klein (1981) has since noted that profit margin erosion and keener competition have affected bank managers so severely that they have had to devise new management techniques. North Carolina's small community banks provide an excellent opportunity to use evaluation processes that are normally employed to study strategic planning and implementation in small businesses because they historically have had broad powers to engage in businesses traditionally not associated with commercial lending (North Carolina Banking Commission 1991, 117). …