JMIR Medical Education · 2019 · 55 citations · 22 references
Life SciencesEducational AssessmentImmunologyClinical ImmunologyImmunogeneticsMolecular ImmunologyDiagnostic ImmunologyHealth Information EvaluationAssessment UsefulnessEducational Resource DevelopmentGene Rearrangement AnalysisImmunoglobulin Heavy Chain RearrangementImmunoglobulin Light Chain RearrangementInformation UsefulnessTest Score ReliabilityUsefulness Assessment
BACKGROUND: The use of the internet as a source of information has grown exponentially in the last decade. YouTube is currently the second most visited website and a major Web-based educational resource for medical students. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the quality, accuracy, and attractiveness of the information acquired from YouTube videos about 2 central concepts in immunology. METHODS: YouTube videos posted before August 27, 2018 were searched using selected keywords related to either antigen presentation or immunoglobulin gene rearrangement. Video characteristics were recorded, and the Video Power Index (VPI) was calculated. Videos were assessed using 5 validated scoring systems: understandability and attractiveness, reliability, content and comprehensiveness, global quality score (GQS), and a subjective score. Videos were categorized by educational usefulness and by source. RESULTS: A total of 82 videos about antigen presentation and 70 about immunoglobulin gene rearrangement were analyzed. Videos had a mean understandability and attractiveness score of 6.57/8 and 5.84/8, content and comprehensiveness score of 9.84/20 and 5.84/20, reliability score of 1.65/4 and 1.53/4, GQS of 3.38/5 and 2.76/5, and subjective score of 2.00/3 and 2.00/3, respectively. The organized channels group tended to have the highest VPI and GQS. CONCLUSIONS: YouTube can provide medical students with some useful information about immunology, although content wise it cannot substitute textbooks and academic courses. Students and teachers should be aware of the educational quality of available videos if they intend to use them in the context of blended learning.
22
Sarah J. Shoemaker, Michael S. Wolf, Cindy Brach · Patient Education and Counseling · 2014 · 1.3K citations
Education, Educational Assessment, Educational Measurement +13