Optimizing genome editing strategy by primer-extension-mediated sequencing

Jianhang Yin, Mengzhu Liu, Yang Liu, Jinchun Wu, Tingting Gan, Weiwei Zhang, Yinghui Li, Yaxuan Zhou, Jiazhi Hu

Cell Discovery · 2019 · 103 citations · 37 references

DOIFull text

Open access

TL;DR

Efficient and precise genome editing is essential for clinical applications and generating animal models, requiring engineered nucleases with high editing ability and low off‑target activity. The study introduces primer‑extension‑mediated sequencing (PEM‑seq) to comprehensively assess editing ability and specificity of engineered nucleases. PEM‑seq is a high‑throughput sequencing method that evaluates both on‑target and off‑target activity of nucleases. PEM‑seq revealed that CRISPR/Cas9 breaks can cause chromosomal translocations and large deletions, that Cas9 nickase reduces off‑target activity at the cost of cleavage efficiency, that high‑fidelity variants eCas9 and FeCas9 markedly lower off‑target effects without impairing editing, that AcrIIA4 suppresses Cas9 activity but less effectively at off‑target sites, and that these insights enable better selection of genome‑editing strategies.

Abstract

Efficient and precise genome editing is essential for clinical applications and generating animal models, which requires engineered nucleases with high editing ability while low off-target activity. Here we present a high-throughput sequencing method, primer-extension-mediated sequencing (PEM-seq), to comprehensively assess both editing ability and specificity of engineered nucleases. We showed CRISPR/Cas9-generated breaks could lead to chromosomal translocations and large deletions by PEM-seq. We also found that Cas9 nickase possessed lower off-target activity while with some loss of target cleavage ability. However, high-fidelity Cas9 variants, including both eCas9 and the new FeCas9, could significantly reduce the Cas9 off-target activity with no obvious editing retardation. Moreover, we found AcrIIA4 inhibitor could greatly reduce the activities of Cas9, but off-target loci were not so effectively suppressed as the on-target sites. Therefore, PEM-seq fully evaluating engineered nucleases could help choose better genome editing strategy at given loci than other methods detecting only off-target activity.

References

37