The Prevailing Injustices in the Application of the Missouri Death Penalty (1978 to 1996)

Michael Lenza, David Patrick Keys, Teresa J. Guess

Social Justice A Journal of Crime Conflict & World Order · 2005 · 15 citations · 15 references

Concepts

Abstract

Introduction GREGG V. GEORGIA (1976) APPROVED THE CONSTITUTIONAL CRITERIA OF GEORGIA statute, Ga. Code Ann., 26-1101 (a) (1972) as a model for the rewriting of state capital punishment laws, one of them Missouri's present revised death penalty statute ([section] 565.020 R.S.Mo. 2000). The majority opinions in Gregg assured Americans that and sentencing was an element of the racist past and that if the provisions in Gregg were followed by lawmakers and practiced by the courts, fair and equitable treatment was possible in the overwhelming majority of cases. This article will argue that the procedural remedies in Gregg have failed to rectify those inequities and that in the instance of the State of Missouri, arbitrary and capricious sentences of death have proceeded in numbers that are exceptional in proportion to its population (Radelet, 1998). This analysis of one state's resumption of capital sentencing over an 18-year period (1978 to 1996) will demonstrate that defendants in capital trials did not receive equal protection under the law and that their fates are still subject to extralegal elements that constitute arbitrariness and capriciousness in Missouri. Second, this article will illustrate that although Gregg (1976) sought to remedy the circumstances that precipitated a significant interruption in the executing of death sentences in the United States via Furman v. Georgia (1972), these remedies have not alleviated the problem of disparate treatment of minorities. Specifically, we maintain that judicial proceedings in Missouri capital cases after 1976 have not been the sources of arbitrariness Gregg sought to remedy. Instead, the actual charging of suspects and prosecutor's plea bargaining with defendants have systematically facilitated harsher outcomes for the alleged assailants of white victims and closely resembles what Paternoster (1983) calls low-visibility decision-making. Furthermore, this analysis will support a view that Missouri's death penalty has changed very little in its essential character from pre-Furman conditions, in that executions continue to be symbolic events with a racist character similar to the legal conditions prevailing in that state before the Civil Rights Movement. Such a system of institutional racism reserves its harshest sanctions for offenders with white victims while unscrupulously waiving the heaviest penalties (e.g., death or life without parole) when the victim is nonwhite. Data Description and Empirical Analyses (1) Data were collected from several sources, the primary one being Missouri Circuit Court Trial Judge Reports (TJR) for the years 1978 to 1996 (n = 574). TJRs are questionnaires that are mandated by statute and completed by the trial judge in a capital or death-eligible case originating in one of Missouri's 45 judicial circuits. Questions range from offender information (e.g., name, social security number, age, ethnicity, years of education completed, and criminal record), circumstances of the crime (usually a narrative description of the events, method, weapon used, and statement of the accused), statutory aggravating and mitigating factors, victim information (age, ethnicity, possible relation to the offender, and reputation in the community), and character of the trial (length in days, legal representation of the defendant, etc.). TJRs varied regarding the companion data (psychological reports, victim impact statements, face sheet from department of corrections, and criminal histories collected by pre-sentence investigations). All reports were provided by the Missouri Supreme Court and processed by the Missouri Office of the Public Defender. In addition, Federal Bureau of Investigation Supplemental Homicide Reports (SHR) were consulted for Missouri data. TJRs were selected for content applicability and because recognized research comparing Missouri TJRs and SHRs (Wallace and Sorensen, 1994) found them to be the most complete and accurate data available, with no significant sampling bias found between the two data sets. …

References

15