Overview of New Pedagogies for Social Change

Susan Roberta Katz, Cecilia Elizabeth O’Leary

Social Justice A Journal of Crime Conflict & World Order · 2002 · 20 citations · 1 references

Concepts

Abstract

As THE UNITED STATES ENTERS THE 21st CENTURY, WE FACE MAJOR CHALLENGES in achieving equity, diversity, and democratic access to higher education. Over the last 50 years, educators and students alike have witnessed both profound gains and losses. A period of significant expansion and transformation took place between the passage of the post-World War II G.I. Bill and the implementation of affirmative action policies during the 1960s to the mid-1970s. This profound democratization of higher was also accompanied by far-ranging in student and faculty The impact of was particularly seen in the design of new courses and the emergence of new social relations on university campuses. The 1978 Supreme Court decision in the Bakke case signaled the contraction of affirmative action policies and the beginning of a profound retrenchment and reorganization of higher education; attacks on affirmative action and on civil and linguistic rights in intensified. By the 1980s, pedagogy and curricula that had once fostered critical analysis began to reflect the political-economic status quo. Separated from its original political base in the civil rights and women's movements, argues Tony Platt (1999: 13), multiculturalism became increasingly apolitical and managerial in its orientation to diversity. An emphasis on cultural contributions - such as food, dance, and music - often replaced critiques of power. Throughout the 1990s, budget cuts in public and public health, paralleled by the unprecedented growth of police and prisons, further narrowed educational opportunities. Today, class inequalities and educational tracking, combined with the rising costs of education, are making it almost impossible for poor students to move up the educational ladder. We need to demand, Platt argues, changes in public policy that recognize the interrelationship of educational, social, and economic issues (Ibid.: 30). Today, educators, students, and communities find themselves at a critical crossroads. This is a time when dialogue and alliances across disciplines and communities need to be forged so that gains from the past are not irrevocably lost and new strategies for teaching and learning can emerge. We offer this special issue of Social Justice as one vehicle toward accomplishing these ends. From around the country, even extending beyond its borders to Brazil, we found individual educators committed to developing learning communities in which critical thinking, collaboration, and active engagement are at the forefront. However, too often these individuals work in small groups and in isolation from each other. A rare example of collaboration in a progressive community exists in a new university, California State University, Monterey Bay (CSUMB). In this issue, we share some of these inspiring examples as well as provide a critical analysis of higher education. Clearly, what we are witnessing today in the U.S. and around the world is the dominance of a new market economy paradigm in the field of education. Local knowledge in the hands of teachers and students is increasingly devalued in contrast to corporate expertise. Discourses of accountability, standards, and high stakes testing are too often used as a mask, disguising real questions: Who controls learning and teaching? What should be the purpose of for historically underrepresented populations? These questions are fraught with tension in our global capitalist society. At the K-12 level, educational decisions such as the language of instruction, the content of the curriculum, and the nature of assessment are no longer made by classroom teachers, or even by local school districts, but by business-directed state and national policies. At the university level, faculty are undergoing increasing pressure to sacrifice academic freedom in the name of standards and to follow a paradigm of outcomes-based education that favors memorization over critical and creative thinking. …

References

1