College Composition and Communication · 1993 · 17 citations · 14 references
EducationScience EducationPedagogyRhetoricWriting InstructionAcademic WritingCompositionalityPractice TheoryReflective PracticeReflective WritingCompositionCompositional PracticeStudent Ownership Of Learning
In her well-known article, The Tacit Tradition, Janet Emig says John Dewey is everywhere in our and names Dewey as a forerunner of contemporary composition research (12). However, since Emig's article appeared in 1980, explications of Dewey's role have been few, although recently these efforts have become more frequent. Louise Phelps, in Composition as a Human Science, finds Dewey's contrast of first-hand experience and reflection central in analyzing what she calls the theory-practice tensions in the composition field (208-11). Tom Newkirk, in the concluding chapter of More than Stories, uses Dewey to develop a compromise between Donald Murray's emphasis upon student ownership and E. D. Hirsch's emphasis upon subject matter (199-208). John Trimbur, in an article on the nature of consensus, considers Dewey's influence upon Kenneth Bruffee and collaborative learning. And, most recently, David Russell, in Writing in the Academic Disciplines. 1870-1990, discusses the significance of two strands of Deweyan progressive education for composition instruction (199-235). My hunch is that the explication of Dewey's work and its consequences for composition has gone slowly because Dewey says so little specifically about writing. But, as Emig suggests, understanding Dewey is essential for understanding ourselves, for understanding the discussion among competing theories of writing which has been the field's focus the past twenty-five years. For example, although contemporary expressivists provide few clues about the philosophic roots of their rhetorical theory, I believe a full explication of Dewey would reveal their indebtedness to the Deweyan tradition. More particularly, I believe a careful study of Dewey in relation to the work of the contemporary expressivist, Peter Elbow, would illustrate the value of Emig's suggestion. In the ongoing debate between expressivists and social con-
14
Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society
Michael McKeon, Raymond Williams · Studies in Romanticism · 1977 · 6.9K citations
Rhetoric and Ideology in the Writing Class
James A. Berlin · College English · 1988 · 364 citations
Consensus and Difference in Collaborative Learning
John Trimbur · College English · 1989 · 267 citations
The Idea of Community in the Study of Writing
Joseph Harris · College Composition and Communication · 1989 · 225 citations