Everyday Consequences of Analytic Thinking

Gordon Pennycook, Jonathan A. Fugelsang, Derek J. Koehler

Current Directions in Psychological Science · 2015 · 361 citations · 38 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study reviews evidence that the willingness to engage analytic reasoning predicts key psychological outcomes in everyday life. The authors conduct a literature review of recent studies on analytic thinking. Analytic thinkers are more skeptical of religious, paranormal, and conspiratorial ideas, hold less traditional moral values, make less emotional moral judgments, are less cooperative and more self‑interested, rely less on smartphones for thinking, and may be more creative, underscoring the broad psychological consequences of analytic thinking.

Abstract

We review recent evidence revealing that the mere willingness to engage analytic reasoning as a means to override intuitive gut feelings is a meaningful predictor of key psychological outcomes in diverse areas of everyday life. For example, those with a more analytic thinking style are more skeptical about religious, paranormal, and conspiratorial concepts. In addition, analytic thinking relates to having less traditional moral values, making less emotional or disgust-based moral judgments, and being less cooperative and more rationally self-interested in social dilemmas. Analytic thinkers are even less likely to offload thinking to smartphone technology and may be more creative. Taken together, these results indicate that the propensity to think analytically has major consequences for individual psychology.

References

38