2009 · 15 citations · 11 references
EducationEducational AssessmentTeachingAthletic TrainingFormative AssessmentSport PedagogyLearning OutcomesLearning StylesSport Skill AcquisitionStudent Learning Outcomes AssessmentAcquisitionsAssessment In Physical EducationComposite Score ConstructionSport-specific Skill Acquisition
The current study examined learning outcomes of three teaching styles in collegiate fundamental volleyball skill classes. Participants were 72 non-physical education major college students who were enrolled in fundamental volleyball skill classes. After an informal skill test the participants were randomly assigned to three groups taught by practice, reciprocal, and inclusion styles. Each group followed the teaching-learning transition patterns of the three teaching strategies as designed by Mosston and Ashworth (19). After eight classes, a validated volleyball skill test battery (1) was utilized to assess skill acquisitions. Scores on passing, setting, and serving constituted a composite score that represented students’ learning outcomes. Results revealed that the mean composite score of the practice group was significantly (p < .01) higher than that of the reciprocal and inclusion groups. No significant difference in the mean composite score was found between the reciprocal and inclusion groups. Furthermore, males scored significantly (p < .01) higher than females in the practice group while females scored significantly (p < .01) higher than males in the inclusion and reciprocal groups. In conclusion, when teaching collegiate fundamental volleyball skills, the three teaching styles toward teaching effectiveness are ranked in descending order as follow: (a) practice, reciprocal, and inclusion styles for males; and (b) inclusion, reciprocal, and practice styles for females.
11