Organization Science · 2001 · 405 citations · 52 references
ManagementOrganization StudiesOrganizational BehaviorDiversification StrategyIndividual DifferencesTeamworkCorporate DiversificationDiversityGroup DiversityResource HeterogeneityTeam CompositionTeam DiversityDependent VariablesOrganizational DiversityTeam Cognitive DiversityTeam Heterogeneity Effects
This article reports partial results of an eight-year field study of the Top Management Teams (TMTs) of a global multidivisional financial services corporation and compares those results with large-sample work in the TMT literature. In particular, it investigates the operationalization of TMT cognitive diversity by the proxies of age, team tenure, industry experience, and functional background heterogeneity most often used in statistical work, and compares those operationalizations with cognitive diversity itself. In addition to highlighting which proxies seemed to most closely approximate cognitive diversity and why, it demonstrates the confounding impact of power on all operationalizations. A comparison of the field results with three representative studies with respect to the operationalization of the dependent variables of diversification, innovation, and performance helps to explain why previous TMT heterogeneity research has often produced inconsistent results or nonfindings. It offers some suggestions that should improve the robustness of statistical research and demonstrates the reciprocal usefulness of case and large-sample research.
52
Building Theories from Case Study Research
Kathleen M. Eisenhardt · Academy of Management Review · 1989 · 16.2K citations
Organizational Strategy, Structure, and Process
Raymond E. Miles, Charles C. Snow, Alan D. Meyer et al. · Academy of Management Review · 1978 · 7.1K citations
Organizational Structure, Environment and Performance: The Role of Strategic Choice
John Child · Sociology · 1972 · 4.8K citations