Representation of the cell and its processes in high school students: An integrated view

Fernando Flores-Camacho, Ma Eugenia Tovar, Leticia Irene Franco Gallegos

International Journal of Science Education · 2003 · 116 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study examines how high‑school students differentiate between plant and animal concepts, organ‑level processes, and cell‑level processes. It aims to provide an integrated view of students’ ideas and conceptual challenges regarding the cell, its processes, structure, and its role in multicellular organisms. The authors surveyed 1,200 students using a questionnaire covering eight cell‑topic areas and analyzed the resulting data. Students demonstrate an analogical mapping between organism‑level functions and cell processes but struggle to distinguish organ‑from‑organism‑level processes, revealing significant conceptual gaps that impact learning. The paper concludes with teaching recommendations.

Abstract

This paper presents an integrated view of the ideas and conceptual problems of high school students with respect to the cell, its processes, structure and relation to the functions of multicellular organisms. The theme of cell has divided into eight topics, with a questionnaire for each topic. In these topics, different levels of representation and understanding are distinguished between general considerations about plants and animals, those connected with processes at organ and system levels and, finally, the level of cell processes. Data from 1200 students were analysed. Results show that students have an analogical mechanism that establishes an isomorphism between the representation of the functioning of multicellular organisms of cell processes. A series of problems in understanding was also shown. Results imply that these problems are mainly due to students' lack of differentiation between some processes at organism and organ level, and have important implications for learning this subject. Finally, some suggestions are made for teaching.