High Ability Studies · 2007 · 277 citations · 164 references
EducationHuman DevelopmentPsychologyCreativityHuman PerformanceIndividual DifferencesAbility ComparisonCharacteristics Of Gifted LearnersCreative PerformanceSkill AcquisitionTalent DevelopmentTalent Development PsychologyAchievement PatternsBody Size AdaptationCognitive SkillsExpert Performance DevelopmentGifted IndividualsInnate BehaviorSustained Superior PerformanceTheoretical Framework Alignment
Giftedness researchers have long debated whether empirical evidence distinguishes giftedness from mere achievement level. This paper proposes a theoretical framework establishing scientific criteria for evidence of superior reproducible performance that any theory of exceptional performance must satisfy. The framework reviews evidence linking superior reproducible performance to extended deliberate practice, physiological adaptations, and complex cognitive mechanisms, and applies the criteria to evaluate claims of innate talent. Except for fixed genetic factors affecting body size and height, no evidence was found for innate constraints on attaining elite achievement in healthy individuals.
Giftedness researchers have long debated whether there is empirical evidence to support a distinction between giftedness and attained level of achievement. In this paper we propose a general theoretical framework that establishes scientific criteria for acceptable evidence of superior reproducible performance, which any theory of exceptional performance must explain. We review evidence for superior reproducible performance, generally emerging only after extended periods of deliberate practice that result in subsequent physiological adaptations and complex cognitive mechanisms. We also apply this framework to examine proposed evidence for innate talents. With the exception of fixed genetic factors determining body size and height, we were unable to find evidence for innate constraints to the attainment of elite achievement for healthy individuals.
164