Ethics & International Affairs · 2002 · 145 citations · 5 references
ManagementOrganization StudiesOrganizational BehaviorCorporate Social ResponsibilityHuman RightsInternational OrganizationsCorporate CitizenshipHuman Rights AdvocacyHuman Rights In BusinessNon-governmental OrganizationsOrganizational EthicsSocial ResponsibilityFace-to-face ConfrontationHuman Rights TheoryNgo AccountabilityNgo AdvocacyNgo CollaborationNon-governmental Human Rights OrganizationsSocial AccountabilitySocial Stigmatization
NGOs differ in tactics toward corporations, with engagers seeking dialogue and voluntary codes, while confronters use moral stigmatization such as naming and shaming. The article aims to describe and evaluate the strategies NGOs use to influence multinational corporations, outlining eight engagement/confrontation approaches. The authors analyze the evolving NGO–MNC relationship and categorize eight strategies along an engagement–confrontation spectrum. The study finds that NGO strategies can move companies toward social responsibility, but sustainable change requires enforceable international legal standards.
This article describes and evaluates the different strategies that have been employed by international human rights nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) in attempting to influence the behavior of multinational corporations (MNCs). Within the NGO world, there is a basic divide on tactics for dealing with corporations: Engagers try to draw corporations into dialogue in order to persuade them by means of ethical and prudential arguments to adopt voluntary codes of conduct, while confronters believe that corporations will act only when their financial interests are threatened, and therefore take a more adversarial stance toward them. Confrontational NGOs tend to employ moral stigmatization, or “naming and shaming,” as their primary tactic, while NGOs that favor engagement offer dialogue and limited forms of cooperation with willing MNCs. The article explains the evolving relationship between NGOs and MNCs in relation to human rights issues and defines eight strategies along the engagement/confrontation spectrum used by NGOs in their dealings with MNCs. The potential benefits and risks of various forms of engagement between NGOs and MNCs are analyzed and it is argued that the dynamic created by NGOs pursuing these different strategies can be productive in moving some companies to embrace their social responsibilities. Yet, in order for these changes to be sustainable, national governments will need to enact enforceable international legal standards for corporate social accountability.
5
National Bureau of Economic Research
Choice Reviews Online · 2003 · 110 citations
Global codes of conduct: an idea whose time has come
Choice Reviews Online · 2000 · 106 citations