Psychological Science · 1994 · 103 citations · 9 references
Social SciencesPsychologySocial PsychologyDecision TheoryExperimental PsychologyIndividual DifferencesJury Decision-makingJury SelectionJury TrialTrial ProcedureAlternative PossibilitiesCoordination TheoryHeuristic JudgmentJuror CompetenceJury Perception Of TestimonyJury ReasoningVerdict Decision ProcessesVerdict Variability
Significant individual variation is observed in how people reason as jurors At the satisficing end of a continuum we identify, the juror draws on evidence selectively to construct a single story of what happened, with no acknowledgment of discrepant evidence or alternative possibilities A contrasting theory-evidence coordination mode of processing entails construction of multiple theories (story-verdict constellations) that are evaluated against the evidence and against alternatives Individual differences influence task outcome, the satisficing mode being associated with more extreme verdict choices and very high certainty
9
Children and adults as intuitive scientists.
Deanna Kuhn · Psychological Review · 1989 · 735 citations
Approaches to studying formal and everyday reasoning.
Kathleen M. Galotti · Psychological Bulletin · 1989 · 299 citations