Human Relations · 2005 · 198 citations · 41 references
ManagementHuman Resource ManagementLabor EconomicsLabor Market AnalysisRecruitmentBoundaryless CareersCareer ChoiceCareer DevelopmentWorkforce DemographicsJob VacanciesJob-to-job MobilityOccupation-specific Vacancies
Contemporary employment scholars have debated “new” or “boundaryless” careers, but we argue that careers are bounded by prior history, occupational identity, and institutional gatekeepers. We present an empirical study of employment outcomes in a mediated labour market. Drawing on placement history and CV data from IT professionals, we examine how occupation‑specific human capital, prior career mobility, and agency relationships affect the probability of being shortlisted for a vacancy. The study shows that a candidate’s prior history with a recruitment agency outweighs occupation‑specific human capital in securing shortlist status, and that prior career mobility actually reduces access to permanent vacancies.
Many scholarly attempts to ascribe meaning to contemporary employment have adopted terms such as ‘new’ or ‘boundaryless’ careers.We argue that it makes more sense to conceptualize careers as ‘bounded’ than as ‘boundaryless’. We argue that careers are bounded by prior career history, occupational identity and by institutional constraints imposed by ‘gatekeepers’ to job opportunities. We present an empirical study of employment outcomes in a mediated labour market. Drawing on placement history and CV data from IT professionals, we examine the impact of occupation-specific human capital, prior career mobility and agency relationships on the probability of being shortlisted for a vacancy. We find that a candidate's prior history with the recruitment agency is a more important factor than occupation-specific human capital in determining access to job vacancies, indicating that intermediaries structure labour market opportunities. Even in a high-turnover industry, prior career mobility has a negative effect on access to permanent vacancies.
41
Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness
Mark Granovetter · American Journal of Sociology · 1985 · 28.2K citations
Journal of economic literature
J. Armstrong · International Journal of Forecasting · 1996 · 10K citations
Investment in Human Capital: A Theoretical Analysis
Gary S. Becker · Journal of Political Economy · 1962 · 7.9K citations
Applied Logistic Regression Analysis
Technometrics · 1996 · 3.6K citations