Deciding for imperilled newborns: medical authority or parental autonomy?

Hazel E McHaffie, Ian Laing, Michael Parker, John McMillan

Journal of Medical Ethics · 2001 · 159 citations · 9 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The ethical issues surrounding infant decision making were highlighted by two empirical studies conducted in Scotland. The study aims to explain the differing perceptions between clinicians and parents regarding decision responsibility. Researchers conducted in‑depth interviews with 176 medical and nursing staff and 108 parents of infants facing treatment withholding or withdrawal to gather data on decision processes and case management. Staff and parents both support involving parents in treatment limitation decisions, yet clinicians feel the responsibility is too great for families while most parents wish to be the final arbiters, and the studies provide ethical reflection and clinical guidance, underscoring the value of empirical data in the debate.

Abstract

The ethical issues around decision making on behalf of infants have been illuminated by two empirical research studies carried out in Scotland. In-depth interviews with 176 medical and nursing staff and with 108 parents of babies for whom there was discussion of treatment withholding/withdrawal, generated a wealth of data on both the decision making process and the management of cases. Both staff and parents believe that parents should be involved in treatment limitation decisions on behalf of their babies. However, whilst many doctors and nurses consider the ultimate responsibility too great for families to carry, the majority of parents wish to be the final arbiters. We offer explanations for the differences in perception found in the two groups. The results of these empirical studies provide both aids to ethical reflection and guidance for clinicians dealing with these vulnerable families. They demonstrate the value of empirical data in the philosophical debate.

References

9